Advertise Here

Eye On Boise

Posts tagged: Online Comments

Anonymous commenter comes forward, identifies herself

A longtime GOP activist and former aide to Idaho Rep. Helen Chenoweth has come forward and identified herself as “AlmostInnocentBystander,” the anonymous commenter on the Huckleberries Online blog whose comment about Kootenai County GOP Chair Tina Jacobson triggered a lawsuit from Jacobson. Linda Cook said Monday that she posted the comment; The Spokesman-Review had been ordered by a court to identify the commenter by Tuesday.

“I would say this is exactly what the First Amendment is about,” said Cook, 54, of Rathdrum, reports S-R reporter Meghann Cuniff. “If you know that someone will come and sue you, which is an expensive proposition, but what you’re bringing out is a matter of public interest, shouldn’t you be able to speak anonymously?” You can read Cuniff's full story here at

S-R columnist: Why defend an anonymous troll’s right to insult?

S-R columnist Shawn Vestal has a provocative column today entitled, “Why defend an anonymous troll's right to insult?” in which he takes on the free-speech arguments in the current case involving an anonymous Huckleberries Online commenter whom the Spokesman-Review is being ordered by a court to identify. “A judge has ordered this newspaper to turn over information about a person who made a potentially libelous comment under an assumed name on the website,” writes Vestal. “This, of course, will have a chilling effect on free speech. A chilling effect is what we in the free-speech business always warn about. We do not want to chill speech; we want it hot and loose. This speech, though? This anonymous lobbing of insults? Chill it. Give it frostbite, even.” You can read his full column here.

L.A. Times: Idaho case suggests online anonymity may be an ‘illusion’…

The L.A. Times analyzes the Idaho court ruling ordering The Spokesman-Review to disclose the identity of an anonymous online commenter in an article today; you can read it here. “When entering the comment forum of your typical news website or blog these days, it sometimes seems like a good idea to wear a helmet,” writes reporter Kim Murphy. “Well-crafted insult? Barbed bombast? Bring it on. Often cloaked in the anonymous protection of screen names, readers feel free to unload on one another, and at the world in general, with impunity. But that protection may be an illusion.”

Get blog updates by email

About this blog

Betsy Z. Russell covers Idaho news from The Spokesman-Review's bureau in Boise.

Named best state-based political blog in Idaho for 2013 by The Fix

Latest comments »

Read all the posts from recent conversations on Eye On Boise.

Search this blog
Subscribe to this blog
Advertise Here