Arrow-right Camera

Spin Control

Idaho could get stuck in this knife fight

There's a switchblade fight going on in Congress. Depending on who wins, North Idaho could bleed jobs at some point.

This is not some latter day version of the Sharks and the Jets, minus the choreography. It's even nastier than some back alley knife fight, because it takes place in an even more dangerous neighborhood: Federal regulations.

The U.S. Customs Bureau recently proposed rewriting the rules governing imported knives to broaden the definition of switchblades. It would expand the ban from the classic switchblade -- think James Coburn in "The Magnificent Seven" -- to any knife that can be opend by one hand with "inertia, gravity or both."

In other words, a knife that can go from fully or partly closed to open with the flick of a wrist. They'd be illegal, just like the classic springloaded switchblade that opens with the press of a button.

That definition, in the words of C.J. Buck, covers a lot of knives. And as the president and chief executive officer of Buck Knives, he'd know.

Right now, the Customs language only covers imported knives. That might seem to be a good thing for Buck Knives, which makes its knives by the thousands in Post Falls. But Buck is afraid there's a very small step to adopting the language for interstate commerce rules, and banning all similar domestic knives, too.

That could effectively ban 60 percent or more of the company's product, which supporting about 220 jobs at the factory just east of the Washington-Idaho border. And factories don't shrink 60 percent, he said: "The die."

Buck said he and other knife manufacturers were caught by surprise by the proposal in May. They called their lobbyist in Congress, and their individual congresspersons. In Buck's case, that was freshman Democrat Walt Minnick.

In the meantime, the Internet lit up with dire warnings that President Obama was out to take your pocket knife as well as your guns. There is no knife equivalent to the National Rifle Association, but many hunting and sportsmen's associations kicked into gear, and the NRA joined the fray.

Minnick, who toured the Post Falls factory last week, told Buck he thought he had the rule squelched last month with a standard legislative maneuer. He and a Republican colleague convinced members of the House Appropriations Committee to accept an amendment to the bill that has the money for the bureau's budget. The amendment cut out the money Customs officilas would need to enforce the rule.

It's a stamdard congressional counterpunch to a rule they don't like: No money, no enforcement.

This time, however, Committee Chairman David Obey said no dice. They weren't going to be making policy through appropriations. (This is a bit like that scene in "Casablanca" where Claude Raines tells Humphrey Bogart he's shocked that gambling is going on at Ricks.)

Minnick said he wishied Obey had said that before he spent hours lobbying every member of the committee because "I wasted a heck of a lot of time on it."

Now he's taking a different tack, of calling customs officials and discussing what the bureau is trying to accomplish. The rule isn't final yet, so there's still time to make changes, he said.

And if that doesn't work? There are other bills moving through the House and "we will attach (the amendment) to something else," Minnick said.

So wil a slogan like "When pocketknives are outlawed only outlaws will have pocketknives" might make a good bumper sticker, it may be a bit early to order up a thousand of them. 

You must be logged in to post comments. Please log in here or click the comment box below for options.

comments powered by Disqus
« Back to Spin Control

The Spokesman-Review's political team keeps a critical eye on local, state and national politics.