Mercy-Killing Claims Shake Hospital Ex-Therapist Says He Sped Deaths Of 40 To 50 Patients
As police tried to determine whether a self-proclaimed mercy killer was a mass murderer or a fraud, people came forward Saturday to tell police their relatives died mysteriously at a hospital that employed him.
“Their loved ones seemed to be OK one day and gone the next,” said Rick Young, spokesman for the Glendale Police Department, which is heading the investigation into the claims by the former respiratory therapist at Glendale Adventist Medical Center.
Police were unsure if Efren Saldivar, who is in his 20s and lives in Los Angeles, told the truth when he admitted killing 40 to 50 terminally ill patients in the last decade.
“We must establish that a crime did in fact occur,” Young said.
Saldivar hasn’t been charged with a crime and remains free while police, prosecutors and medical regulators continue with their investigations. His license was suspended March 13, regulators announced Friday.
News of the confession shocked patients’ relatives.
Ana Spann went to the hospital Saturday with questions about her 95-year-old grandmother, Juana Souza, who died Jan. 10, 1996, while undergoing respiratory treatments for pneumonia.
“I want to know: Did she die in her sleep, did she feel pain, or did somebody murder her?” said Spann, 39, of Alta Loma. “We thought that God had taken her. I hope it was like that, and not somebody had taken her life.”
Inundated with calls from the media and relatives, the 450-bed, 1,800-employee hospital in the Los Angeles suburb distributed a letter to all of its patients Saturday to outline the allegations and explain why it suspended its entire 44-member respiratory care department.
“We want to assure you that we firmly believe there is no reason for concern regarding safety,” it said. “We have taken every reasonable precaution to protect patients and we are committed to doing whatever it takes to get to the truth in this investigation.”
Saldivar told a police investigator earlier this month that he was an “angel of death” who killed patients he deemed to be on the verge of dying anyway through suffocation or drug injection, state medical regulators said.
Friday’s announcement, in response to media calls to the state Respiratory Care Board, caught investigators by surprise, Young said.
“We were angry to begin with, and now we are totally frustrated as it has hampered this investigation 100 times fold,” said Young, who noted that some hospital employees have become reluctant to cooperate for fear their names will be revealed.
Kathleen McCoy, executive officer of the state’s Respiratory Care Board, which released the documents, responded that they officially became public once an administrative law court suspended Saldivar’s license for 30 days. The court placed no secrecy order on the documents.
“We did not want to hamper their investigation, but these are public documents,” McCoy said.
Saldivar faces a hearing Tuesday on whether regulators may permanently suspend his license.
He was jailed earlier this month but released two days later for lack of evidence pending further investigation - a situation that legal analysts say is not uncommon.
“If they don’t believe he’s a flight risk, they are better off releasing him and developing a case that will actually stick than holding him on superficial charges,” said Carol Chase, a law professor at Pepperdine University.
Police have been interviewing patients’ relatives and reviewing hospital files, and they were strongly considering exhuming some bodies.
In a statement to the state regulatory board, Glendale police Officer William Currie described a March 11 interview in which Saldivar waived his right to have a lawyer present.
“Saldivar talked about his anger at seeing patients kept alive as opposed to the guilt he would feel at the failure of providing lifesaving care,” Currie said. A polygraph examiner “asked Saldivar if he considered himself an angel of death. Saldivar replied yes.”
Gloria A. Barrios, a state deputy attorney general, wrote in court papers seeking the license suspension that “there is no reason to believe” that Saldivar would concoct the story, adding that his “statements cannot simply be discounted as the rantings of a person seeking attention.”
Another question is whether Saldivar acted alone. In the statement to regulators, Currie said: “Saldivar said he felt encouraged by other therapists at (Glendale Adventist) who would sometimes give him room numbers of patients who needed lethal injections.”
Saldivar could not be reached for comment Friday or Saturday. His brother, Eddie, said Friday the allegations could not be true and that his brother’s life “is being torn apart by something someone said.”
Currie said it was Saldivar himself who admitted killing with either lethal injections of Pavulon and succinylcholine chloride - both paralyzing medications - or by decreasing oxygen to patients relying on a ventilator.
Saldivar told him that patients had to be unconscious, have a do-not-resuscitate order and “they had to look like they were ready to die,” Currie said.
The hospital first heard rumors about hastened patient deaths in April 1997, hospital officials have said. A two-month internal investigation revealed nothing suspicious.
The criminal investigation began after police received an anonymous phone call on March 3 from a person who said Saldivar “helped a patient die fast” about Feb. 16, Currie said.