Clinic violence not racketeering

WASHINGTON – The Supreme Court ended a 20-year-old lawsuit against militant anti-abortion groups Tuesday, ruling unanimously that their use of “physical violence” outside clinics did not violate anti-racketeering laws.

The decision marked the third time this case had been decided by the Supreme Court, and this time, they made sure it would be the last.

The effect of the ruling will be limited, however, because a federal law enacted in 1994 makes it illegal to block the entrances to an abortion clinic.

The lawsuit that ended Tuesday began during an era of abortion clinic bombings in the 1980s. At the same time, anti-abortion groups such as Operation Rescue employed “human blockades” to try to stop pregnant patients from entering clinics.

Searching for a legal weapon to combat such tactics, the National Organization for Women sued Operation Rescue and its leaders for violating the federal anti-racketeering law. This law incorporates other federal measures, including the laws against robbery and extortion.

The Supreme Court allowed this suit to go forward in 1994, and a jury in Chicago ruled that the protesters had used force and, on occasion, violence to prevent patients and staff from entering clinics. A judge assessed damages against Operation Rescue and issued a nationwide order forbidding its members from blocking clinics.

Three years ago, the Supreme Court appeared to reverse course. It ruled that the protesters did not engage in “extortion” when they blocked clinics because they were not seeking to take over these businesses.

The justices sent the case back to Chicago, apparently assuming it was over. But a U.S. appeals court there said that because violence was used on several occasions, the lawsuit could continue.

In Tuesday’s ruling, the justices said they meant to end the case entirely. Because the protesters had not engaged in extortion, they did not violate the anti-racketeering law in the first place.

While the lawsuit was languishing in the lower courts, Congress passed the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994. It makes it a crime to block health clinics, and it also permits clinic operators to sue if their rights under the law are violated.