Documents’ removal concerns lawmakers
WASHINGTON – A congressional committee will look into a secret program under which federal intelligence agencies have withdrawn thousands of historical documents from public access at the National Archives, even though the records had been declassified.
“We are spending literally millions and millions of dollars to keep secrets from ourselves,” said Rep. Christopher Shays, R-Conn., chairman of the Government Reform subcommittee on national security, emerging threats and international relations. “We’ve got a huge problem.”
The panel plans to hold an oversight hearing March 14 on federal policies for the handling of sensitive information. Shays said the suppression of documents that pose no threat to national security is indicative of a larger problem in which government secrecy is on the rise.
About 9,500 records totaling more than 55,000 pages have been withdrawn from the public shelves and reclassified since 1999, according to the National Archives. The New York Times reported last month that outside historians discovered the practice and complained about it. Archivist Allen Weinstein announced a moratorium on the reclassification efforts Thursday.
While the archives will not name the agencies involved, historians with the National Security Archive, a nonprofit research library at George Washington University, say the Central Intelligence Agency, Defense Intelligence Agency, Defense Department and Justice Department have participated.
Many of the records date to the 1940s and 1950s and their continued disclosure would pose no conceivable security risk, said historians who obtained copies of the records before reclassification. Such documents include old Cold War intelligence analyses and studies of political affairs in Mexico in the 1960s. Other documents appear to be the sort that should not have been declassified, historians say.
Weinstein said he is suspending the agencies’ efforts to withdraw documents until the archives’ Information Security Oversight Office completes an audit of the removed material. Results of the audit, which will help determine which records should be secret, are expected by late April.
“I felt that it was important to give people time to cool off in this whole matter,” Weinstein said Friday. “It’s an effort to slow the trains down.”
The program dates to the Clinton administration, when the CIA and other agencies began recalling documents they believed were improperly released under a 1995 executive order requiring declassification of many historical records 25 years old and older. The pace of the removal picked up after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks.
Some documents appear to have been withdrawn for no reason other than to spare official embarrassment, historians said. One document – excerpts of an Oct. 12, 1950, memo from the CIA director to President Harry S. Truman – says that while Chinese intervention in the Korean War was possible, “a consideration of all known factors leads to the conclusion that barring a Soviet decision for global war, such action is not probable in 1950.” The Chinese invaded Korea on Nov. 26.