House official slams leader’s spouse
OLYMPIA – House Republicans lambasted trial lawyers during raucous debate Thursday. But when one lawmaker singled out the Democratic House majority leader’s husband for scorn, the place erupted in shouts.
An eventual apology was angrily rejected.
The presiding officer, who tried in vain to keep the peace, called it the worst breach of decorum he’d ever seen in the Legislature.
The dustup involved two of the most powerful lobbies in Olympia – trial lawyers, who often support Democrats, and the insurance industry, which often backs Republicans.
The debate was over the proposed Insurance Fair Conduct Act, which would prohibit the practice of delaying or denying a claim without proper cause. It would allow the policyholder to collect triple damages if the insurance company unreasonably denied a claim or violated unfair practice rules.
From the start, Republicans denounced trial lawyers as money-grubbers who would hurt insurance companies, clog the courts and drive up premiums.
“I wouldn’t even refer to this as the full employment act for trial lawyers – it is the full retirement act because they’ll be able to retire when they make all this money at the expense of the people of Washington state,” said Rep. Doug Ericksen, R-Ferndale, deputy minority leader.
He said trial lawyers were pushing “an extreme, radical bill.”
Insurance Committee Chairman Steve Kirby, D-Tacoma, retorted that the industry has some bad apples.
Back and forth it went, with Speaker Pro Tem John Lovick, D-Mill Creek, trying unsuccessfully to rein in the rhetoric.
Rep. David Buri, R-Colfax, soon blistered trial lawyers, saying they want to “continue to cheat and plunder our policyholders.”
On the other side, Rep. Geoff Simpson, D-Covington, accused “our friends on the other side of the aisle” of defending the practice of unscrupulous insurers cheating consumers.
Then, it got personal. Rep. Dan Roach, R-Bonney Lake, said it is “very, very concerning” that only trial lawyers are pushing the bill.
“This is not for the consumers,” he said. “This will increase costs to the consumer. It is a sad day.”
After being gaveled down for impugning the sponsors’ motives, he said, “Look out! The train is coming through! The Keith Kessler train is coming through and you better get out of the way.”
Keith Kessler is one of the state’s most prominent trial lawyers, a former president of the state trial lawyers and the husband of House Majority Leader Lynn Kessler, D-Hoquiam.
Lovick sternly admonished Roach again for breaking House rules of decorum. Lawmakers aren’t supposed to refer to colleagues by name or criticize members’ families.
An angry Lynn Kessler demanded an apology. None was forthcoming and the House broke for 15 minutes while Lovick waited for lawmakers to simmer down.
Eventually, when the House reconvened, Roach offered an apology of sorts.
The bill then passed on a mostly party-line vote, 59-38.