December 23, 2009 in Nation/World

AIG bonuses not returned

Many vowed to repay, now have lawyers, report says
Brady Dennis Washington Post
 

When word spread earlier this year that American International Group had paid more than $165 million in retention bonuses at the division that had precipitated the company’s downfall, outrage erupted, with employees getting death threats and President Barack Obama urging that every legal avenue be pursued to block the payments.

New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo threatened to publicize the recipients’ names, prompting executives at AIG Financial Products to hastily agree to return about $45 million in bonuses by the end of the year.

But as the final days of 2009 tick away, a majority of that money remains unpaid. Only about $19 million has been given back, according to a report by the special inspector general for the government’s bailout program.

Some of the employees who had offered to return their bonuses have instead left the company, taking their cash with them.

Others remain at Financial Products but are also holding on to their money until they see what Kenneth Feinberg, the Obama administration’s “compensation czar,” decides about whether they should get future bonus payments they have also been promised. Feinberg, AIG and government officials have been involved in ongoing negotiations over the status of past and future bonuses at the insurance giant.

Dozens of employees have hired lawyers, bracing for a fight if AIG or government officials try to block the payments.

When the controversy erupted in March, Cuomo agreed to keep the employees’ identities secret as long as a significant share of the money was returned to the company. Some of them said his demand amounted to blackmail. But AIG officials said at the time that at least 18 of the firm’s top 25 executives had agreed to return at least some of their bonus money.

But now, the government, AIG and the employees are on a collision course. Everyone is keenly aware that another round of retention payments at Financial Products is due soon, threatening to draw public attention to the issue once again. AIG is scheduled to pay out an additional $198 million to employees in March.

“They have a contractual right to be paid this money. They put in their time, and they have performed all their obligations successfully,” said Andrew Goodstadt, a New York lawyer who represents more than a dozen Financial Products employees. “They’re willing to assert their contractual rights in a court of law. They have extremely strong claims.”

Goodstadt said his clients include computer systems specialists, mathematicians and other employees who did not have a hand in the risky credit derivatives that brought the firm down. Rather, he said, many employees who remain at Financial Products have worked to unwind the troubled trades on its books and protect the massive taxpayer investment in AIG, whose total rescue package peaked at more than $180 billion in capital and loans.

They stuck around, he said, in large part because of the company’s promise of the retention payments. In addition, Goodstadt emphasized that the company told employees in March that their offers to return bonus payments were voluntary and nonbinding.

People familiar with recent discussions between Feinberg and executives at AIG said Feinberg has insisted that Financial Products employees return the money they said they would before he signs off on any deal involving 2010 compensation.


There is one comment on this story. Click here to view comment >>

Get stories like this in a free daily email