Local news

Mother gets 10 years for daughter’s injuries


Kyra Wine, 3, lost both feet and one kidney as a result of abuse, neglect

ST. MARIES – Last summer, when police discovered her, Kyra Wine was covered with scars, bruises, feces and signs of horrible abuse. Sections of her scalp were torn away, and dead skin covered her hands and feet.

On Friday, the girl’s mother received the maximum sentence possible for felony injury to a child.

Testimony about Christina Haynes’ mental state didn’t sway a judge from imposing a 10-year prison sentence on the woman whose child almost died in one of the worst neglect cases in Benewah County.

Haynes’ mental-health issues didn’t excuse her from seeking medical help for her 3-year-old daughter, 1st District Judge Fred Gibler said.

The girl almost died as a result of injuries suffered at the hands of Haynes and her boyfriend, Charles W. Smith. Kyra’s feet were amputated and she lost a kidney, part of a finger and has patches on her head where hair won’t grow back. Gibler said the 27-year-old Haynes probably wasn’t as culpable as Smith, who was sentenced earlier this spring to a maximum 10 years for child abuse. But Haynes is responsible for allowing Smith to care for her children, the judge said at Haynes’ sentencing. Haynes met Smith online and invited him to live with her and her children at a farm north of St. Maries.

Haynes’ 10-year sentence includes five years in prison and five years indeterminate time.

In arguing for the prison time, Benewah County Prosecutor Doug Payne said Haynes had a higher level of responsibility than her boyfriend.

“She is the child’s mother,” Payne said. “How can a child’s mother let this happen?”

Pamela Olsen, a psychologist for the state, testified that Haynes suffered from disassociation, a form of denial that prohibited her from understanding the severity of Kyra’s injuries or the charges against her.

“She didn’t have the capacity to address this situation in a problem-solving way and take action to do something,” Olsen said. Haynes’ lawyer, Benewah County public defender Dave Rodgers, said he postponed earlier arraignments because he couldn’t comprehend the actions of his client, who wouldn’t respond to his inquiries.

It was not until months after her arrest – when he and Christina’s mother, Linda Yarber, showed Haynes pictures of Kyra’s injuries – that the 27-year-old seemed to understand the extent of the charges.

Payne, the prosecutor, argued that the defendant knew how extreme her daughter’s injuries were because she prohibited neighbors, friends and relatives from seeing the girl before county deputies made a welfare check at the Hells Gulch home in June 2008.

After a lengthy psychological evaluation, Haynes pleaded guilty in May to felony injury to a child, which carries a maximum 10 years in prison.

She wept in court Friday.

“I’m sorry,” she said. “I know I screwed up.”

After sentencing, her mother, who was accompanied by family members, cried quietly.

“It’s hard for us to understand that she is guilty of doing something she didn’t understand,” Yarber said. “She couldn’t believe that she had done something like that.”

Kyra, who has two prosthetic feet, was released from Sacred Heart Medical Center last autumn. She and her sister are living at their paternal grandparents’ St. Maries home.

There are two comments on this story »



Contact the Spokesman

Main switchboard:
(509) 459-5000
Customer service:
(509) 747-4422
(509) 459-5400
(800) 789-0029
Back to Spokesman Mobile