October 22, 2009 in Washington Voices

Congregation moves uphill

Century-old church makes way for freeway project
By The Spokesman-Review
 
J. BART RAYNIAK photo

The Bethany Presbyterian Church at Third Avenue and Freya Street is known for it’s controversial signs. The church will be torn down to widen Interstate 90.
(Full-size photo)

Joint celebration

Bethany Presbyterian, Emmanuel Metropolitan Community and Bethlehem Lutheran churches will hold a joint worship service and Oktoberfest celebration Sunday at 10:30 a.m. at Bethlehem Lutheran, 2715 S. Ray St. For details, see the Religion Notebook/Page 2.

Fast fact

The Emmanuel Metropolitan Community Church that shared the church building on South Freya with Bethany Presbyterian Church, also will relocate to Bethlehem Lutheran Church on South Ray Street.

It’s been there for 100 years and most people know it as “that church with the sign” that grabs motorists’ attention with its pointed messages.

Bethany Presbyterian Church is moving from the corner of South Freya Street and East Third Avenue because the Washington State Department of Transportation has purchased the land the church sits on for an expansion of Interstate 90.

“This congregation has done a dance with freeways almost half of its life,” said Rev. Paul Rodkey of Bethany Presbyterian Church. “Actually, the state gave us a real blessing by buying us. We have chosen to see this as a blessing, and it is a choice how you chose to respond to the change in the world around you.”

The congregation of about 90 people – including 10 who joined at the last service in the old church Sunday – plans to share space with Bethlehem Lutheran Church on South Ray Street. The gay-friendly Emmanuel Metropolitan Community Church, which was housed at Bethany Presbyterian Church, is also moving into the Lutheran church.

“Wherever we would move we would invite EMCC to come with us,” said Rodkey. “I can see how for frightened and ignorant Christians that could be terrifying, but for us it’s just a statement of our belief and hospitality. And Bethlehem Lutheran has been absolutely welcoming.”

The famous sign, however, has been put up for sale.

“We will not get the same traffic up there as we did here,” said Rodkey. “When we started talking about moving, the first question was how are we going to talk to Spokane if we don’t have the sign?”

Over the years, messages on the sign have caused uproar, laughter and conversation. Rodkey said that among the messages that got the most response were: “The Christian right is neither,” “The moral majority is not,” “Fundamentalism in all religions is the problem not the solution,” and, “Who would Jesus bomb?”

“We know we tick some people off with that sign, and we are OK with that,” said Rodkey. “When we got the sign we decided to not just put passive Christian drivel up there – we wanted to have a conversation with the people who drove by.”

Rodkey is not sure how long his congregation will stay at Bethlehem Lutheran Church. Come January the congregation will start planning for a new church building and location.

He said many of the church buildings from the 1940s and ’50s are ineffective, cumbersome and expensive for churches today. Suggestions for a new location are very welcome, Rodkey added, explaining that he likes the size of the congregation and isn’t looking to expand into a huge setting.

“This is not a huge church, but we like it like that,” Rodkey said. “A big church becomes a business and we don’t want to be a business; we want to be a church.”

If anyone has a temporary location for a reader board, the congregation may be open to ideas.

“In our new location we are going to have a new reader board as well,” Rodkey said.

For now, he’s busy packing up and getting ready for a public auction to be held at the old church on Oct. 28 at 5 p.m. Leaving the current church location behind is not easy.

“We have been on this corner for 100 years, there are so many layers of ‘ouch’ that I can’t even begin to tell you how hard it is,” said Rodkey. “But it’s not like this sneaked up on us, we knew this would happen. And the congregation has a wonderful positive attitude.”


Thoughts and opinions on this story? Click here to comment >>

Get stories like this in a free daily email