Spokane7
39°
September 13, 2009 in City
Feds unhappy with city attorney
Treppiedi defends actions in Zehm-related case
Federal prosecutors have grown increasingly critical of what they describe as questionable behavior by the Spokane Police Department’s chief legal adviser, who reportedly used his position to provide “traditionally confidential” information to the officer under FBI investigation following the fatal confrontation with Otto Zehm.
In documents filed recently in U.S. District Court, prosecutors describe a pattern of behavior by Assistant Spokane City Attorney Rocky Treppiedi that raises questions about whether the city actively sought to interfere with the federal investigation that led to a grand jury indictment of Officer Karl F. Thompson. Treppiedi disputes any suggestion that he has acted improperly.
But in court filings, Assistant U.S. Attorney Tim Durkin has advised the judge presiding over the criminal case against Thompson of the following:
•Treppiedi “prepped and debriefed” the majority of the police officers and other city employees subpoenaed to testify before the federal grand jury deciding whether criminal charges should be filed, despite a gag order imposed by Spokane police Chief Anne Kirkpatrick.
•Treppiedi channeled “traditionally confidential grand jury information to the federally targeted defendant” – Thompson – that the attorney received during the debriefings of other city employees appearing before the grand jury.
•An expert hired by Treppiedi to enhance the video of the fatal encounter concluded that Thompson did not use his police baton on Zehm for the first 73 seconds of the struggle, despite Thompson’s own statements to the contrary.
•On June 21, 2006, Treppiedi issued a letter that was posted on the city of Spokane’s Web site that “exonerated” Thompson of using “excessive force” before the police department’s own investigation was completed.
Treppiedi said he’s unaware of any concerns surrounding his actions in the case. “There isn’t anything inappropriate in terms of the few simple filings that have been made so far,” he said in a telephone message.
City Attorney Howard Delaney and Chief Kirkpatrick did not return phone calls seeking comment. City spokeswoman Marlene Feist said in an e-mail that city officials do not anticipate commenting on the case until its conclusion.
Two legal ethicists asked by The Spokesman-Review to review the court filings, however, said the case raises troubling questions about whose interest the city is representing.
“The public interest is in having a well-run police department,” said John Strait, an ethics professor at Seattle University School of Law. “And if one of those unusual cases of bad police conduct has occurred, it is important to assure that the public interest is being fulfilled unaffected by the interest of the individual officer.”
University of Washington law professor Rob Aronson said that if the actions described in court documents are accurate, it appears to be misuse of a public position.
“To the extent that (Treppiedi) used his position to thwart a department gag order and obtain secret grand jury information and funnel it to the target of a criminal investigation, his conflict of interest would be clear, as well as an abuse of his position,” Aronson said.
Thompson was the first police officer to confront Zehm, a mentally ill janitor mistakenly identified as a robbery suspect on March 18, 2006. In the struggle that followed, the unarmed Zehm was beaten with a police baton, shocked several times with a Taser and eventually overpowered by a half-dozen officers who then hogtied him on the floor of a convenience store and put a plastic mask over his face. Zehm lapsed into a coma and died without regaining consciousness.
Thompson argues that Zehm refused to drop a plastic soda bottle, which the officer feared could be used as a weapon against him.
The grand jury, however, indicted Thompson on charges of using unreasonable force to detain Zehm and of lying to investigators. A U.S. District Court trial is scheduled to begin Feb. 8.
The city is paying private attorney Carl Oreskovich up to $200,000 to defend Thompson against a civil lawsuit brought by the public interest law firm Center for Justice on behalf of Zehm’s mother.
But according to Durkin’s court filing, Treppiedi has conducted a “shadow grand jury” that blurred the boundaries between representing the city in the civil case and defending Thompson against the criminal charges.
Durkin wrote that Treppiedi “has opined that since he personally represents and continues to personally represent the Defendant Karl Thompson, that he is obligated to disclose to the target of the federal criminal investigation (i.e., the Defendant Karl Thompson) and his counsel Carl Oreskovich information from the Grand Jury proceedings that has traditionally remained confidential.”
Aronson, the legal ethicist, said it’s troubling because a city attorney’s role should have been supporting efforts of the grand jury to seek the truth “and not preparing witnesses to support the defendant.”
“Here, it looks as though the city attorney, prior to the completion of a reasonable investigation, immediately went into ‘defense-attorney mode,’ and worked virtually exclusively to defend the alleged criminal and gather evidence in support of his civil (and, thus at the same time, his criminal) defense.”
Oreskovich declined comment, saying, “That needs to come from either Mr. Durkin or Mr. Treppiedi.”
Durkin and U.S. Attorney Jim McDevitt both said they could not comment and referred all questions to the court documents. Likewise, Jeffry Finer, of the Center for Justice, declined comment on the civil case.
Lawyer defends Zehm handling 
Historic Map of Spokane 
Order your "Fish Playing Poker" print 
Pick the Perfect Bracket and win $100,000 
Enter for a chance to win a fancy DTE water bottle!
Win 2 tickets to the Knitting Factory!
Win $20 to Frontier West Family Restaurant
Bob_Knows on September 13 at 8:01 a.m.
Corrupt criminal politicians kept in power by an army of murderous thugs. No surprises in this article at all.
Bob
Flag as inappropriate
westside on September 13 at 9:43 a.m.
Treppiedi is just one of the 'boys' in the police dept…just generally dishonest officials with high price tags …”Rocky”..says it all!!!
Flag as inappropriate
Lulubelle on September 13 at 12:01 p.m.
boy does this revelation make the upcoming school board election difficult…..our only choices are two HUGE losers…..a seemingly corrupt attorney and a loon that wants the bible used as a text book. This, along with the tepid decision by district 81 to okay the showing of the President's speech will make supporting this school board and district with votes in favor of school bonds a little dicey. At least I'll be thinking twice…
Flag as inappropriate
Spokane_PI on September 13 at 1:20 p.m.
Just more evidence of government corruption. Instead of working for the people of Spokane “Rocky” is working for his own interests and the interests of his buddies in the police dept.. Justice is served by the truth coming to light. Something the Spokane PD and County Prosecutors Office completely ignore.
I hope the Federal Prosecutors take a good look at the original video and have a chat with the video consultant about what “Rocky” asked him to do.
Federal Prosecutors should seriously consider filing obstructing charges against “Rocky”.
Flag as inappropriate
flutieflakes on September 13 at 4:51 p.m.
I hope the feds come in and clean all this shiz up, from Kirkpatrick and Rocky down to Thompson, Olsen and the rest of the pig's union. This is getting embarrassing, and the public is rightfully getting pissed. They shouldn't see another dime from Spokane voters until they fix the various processes within city governance that are obviously broken and HEADS ROLL!
Flag as inappropriate
Gramma on September 13 at 8:32 p.m.
What ever happened to innocent until proven guilty?
You are all a bunch of naysayers that NEVER have anything good to say about the police or any one in authority.
Flag as inappropriate
Rifleman_Dodd on September 15 at 4:17 p.m.
Funny how Steele and Morlin detailed all of this over TWO years ago and just now the Feds are pulling their heads out of their anal-cranial hiding spot.
shame on McDevitt.. for not commenting.
shame on Kirkpatrict for keeping him arround after violating her own gag order.
shame on the City Council for not filing a RPC violation.
shame, shame, shame.
Flag as inappropriate