Spokane, Kootenai could violate EPA’s stricter smog limits
WASHINGTON — The Environmental Protection Agency on Thursday proposed stricter health standards for smog, replacing a Bush-era limit that ran counter to scientific recommendations.
The new limits — which are presented as a range — could put Spokane, Kootenai and hundreds of other counties nationwide in violation, a designation that would require them to find additional ways to clamp down on pollution or face government sanctions, most likely the loss of federal highway dollars.
The tighter standards will cost tens of billions of dollars to implement, but will ultimately save billions in avoided emergency room visits, premature deaths, and missed work and school days, the EPA said.
The proposed range was what scientists had recommended during the Bush administration. However, former President George W. Bush personally intervened and set the standard above what was advised after protests from electric utilities and other industries. The Bush standard was still stricter than the previous smog standard set in 1997.
EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson said that science, this time around, had been followed.
“EPA is stepping up to protect Americans from one of the most persistent and widespread pollutants we face,” Jackson said. “Using the best science to strengthen these standards is long overdue action that will help millions of Americans breathe easier and live healthier.”
The EPA proposal presents a range for the allowable concentration of ground-level ozone, the main ingredient in smog, from 60 parts per billion to 70 parts per billion. EPA will select a specific figure within that range later this year.
While smog has been a long-term problem in parts of Texas, California, and along the northeast Coast, the new standards could affect counties in Idaho, Nevada, Oregon, the Dakotas, Kansas, Minnesota and Iowa for the first time.
Smog levels in Spokane and Kootenai counties were measured at 64 parts per billion from 2006 to 2008. Levels for both counties are recorded at a Green Bluff monitor.
Locally, smog concentrations have dropped in recent years, said Ron Edgar, the Spokane Regional Clean Air Agency’s chief of technical services. He credited more efficient cars for the lower levels, along with gas stations that outfit their pumps with vapor shields. The nozzles capture escaping gasoline vapors, which are pumped back into the customer’s tank. The recession might also be contributing to less smog through fewer industrial emissions, Edgar said.
If Spokane County fails to meet the new emission standards, Edgar said industries would face tougher emission limits. Tighter vapor controls would be required at gas stations and automotive paint shops.
The Obama administration last year had indicated it planned to scrap the Bush smog limits of 75 parts per billion, when it asked a federal judge to stay a lawsuit challenging the March 2008 standards brought by 11 states and environmental groups.
Smog levels typically peak in July and August on hot, windless days. Smog is a respiratory irritant that has been linked to asthma attacks and other respiratory illnesses. It is formed when emissions from burning gasoline, power and chemical plants, refineries and other factories mix in sunlight.
Environmentalists immediately endorsed the decision. “If EPA follows through, it will mean significantly cleaner air and better health protection,” said Frank O’Donnell, president of the advocacy group Clean Air Watch.
Representatives of the oil and gas industry, which said they have already invested $175 billion toward environmental improvements, were quick to say the proposal lacked “scientific justification.”
“There is absolutely no basis for EPA to propose changing the ozone standards promulgated by the EPA Administrator in 2008,” the American Petroleum Institute said in a statement. “To do so is an obvious politicization of the air quality standard setting process that could mean unnecessary energy cost increases, job losses and less domestic oil and natural gas development and energy security.”
The stricter limit comes with additional costs, from $19 billion up to $90 billion a year by 2020, according to EPA. The Bush administration had put the cost to industry and drivers to meet its standard at between $7.6 billion to $8.5 billion a year.
Counties and states will have up to 20 years to meet the new limits, depending on how severely they are out of compliance. They will have to submit plans for meeting the new limits by end of 2013 or early 2014.
8-hour Ground-level Ozone Concentrations:
The EPA proposal presents a range for the allowable concentration of ground-level ozone, the main ingredient in smog, from 60 parts per billion to 70 parts per billion. EPA will select a specific figure within that range later this year. Based on monitored air quality from 2006-2008, Spokane and Kootenai counties could violate the new levels.
Spokane County: 64 parts per billion
Kootenai County: 64 parts per billion
Staff writer Becky Kramer contributed to this report.