Arrow-right Camera


Romney’s job record mixed

SUNDAY, DEC. 4, 2011

Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney speaks at a town hall meeting in The Villages, Fla., on Oct. 4. (Associated Press)
Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney speaks at a town hall meeting in The Villages, Fla., on Oct. 4. (Associated Press)

Bain Capital more focused on profitability

WASHINGTON – Shortly after Mitt Romney resigned from Bain Capital in 1999 to run the Olympics in Salt Lake City, potential investors received a prospectus touting the extraordinary profits earned by the private equity company he controlled for 15 years.

During that time, Boston-based Bain acquired more than 115 companies, according to the prospectus. Bain’s estimated annual returns were more than five times that of the Dow Jones industrial average in the same period.

Now a front-runner for the Republican presidential nomination, Romney says his Bain experience shows he knows how to create jobs. He often cites Bain’s investment in a little-known office supply store called Staples, which now employs more than 90,000 worldwide.

But a closer examination of the prospectus paints a different picture of Bain’s operation. Under Romney’s leadership, Bain became one of the nation’s top leveraged buyout companies, helping lead a trend in which businesses were acquired using debt often pledged against their own assets or earnings.

Bain expanded many of the companies it acquired. But like other LBO companies, Romney and his team also maximized returns by firing workers, seeking government subsidies, and flipping companies quickly for large profit. Sometimes Bain investors gained even when companies slid into bankruptcy.

Not about job creation

Romney himself became wealthy at Bain. He is now worth between $190 million and $250 million, much of it derived from his time running the investment company, his campaign staffers have said.

Bain managers said their mission was clear. “I never thought of what I do for a living as job creation,” said Marc Walpow, a former managing partner at Bain who worked closely with Romney. “The primary goal of private equity is to create wealth for your investors.”

Bain’s top 10 dollar investments under Romney – averaging $53 million – spanned a number of sectors from health care to entertainment to manufacturing. The company’s largest investment was its 1999 buyout of Domino’s Pizza, into which Bain put $188.8 million, eventually reaping a fivefold return.

Four of the 10 companies Bain acquired declared bankruptcy within a few years, shedding thousands of jobs. The prospectus shows that Bain investors profited in eight of the 10 deals, including three of the four that ended in bankruptcy.

Shift toward buyouts

Romney launched Bain Capital in 1984 after seven years at Bain and Co., a highly regarded consulting firm that he joined two years after finishing Harvard Business School. Company founder Bill Bain tapped Romney to establish Bain Capital as a separate company that would draw from Bain & Co.’s consulting acumen to buy promising companies and invest in new ones.

Bain Capital’s portfolio started with a preponderance of simple investments like Staples, but shifted heavily toward more complex leveraged buyout and other deals within several years, according to former Bain partners.

LBOs allow investors to purchase businesses with sometimes significant amounts of debt. To critics, these leveraged deals can make acquired companies more vulnerable to economic downturns, leading to a greater likelihood of bankruptcy and job cuts. At the same time, the deals sometimes introduce discipline to companies and even whole industries that need it.

Either way, Bain investors typically profited.

GSI failure

That was true in the case of GS Industries, the 10th biggest Bain investment in the Romney years. Bain formed GSI in the early 1990s by spending $24 million to acquire and merge steel companies with plants in Missouri, South Carolina and other states.

Company managers cut jobs and benefits almost immediately. Meanwhile, Bain and other investors received management fees from GSI and a $65 million dividend in the first years after the acquisition, according to interviews with company employees.

In 1999, as economic challenges mounted, GSI sought a federal loan guarantee intended to help steel companies compete internationally. The loan deal was approved but before it could be used, the company went bankrupt in 2001, two years after Romney left Bain.

More than 700 workers were fired, losing not only their jobs but health insurance, severance and a chunk of their pension benefits. GSI retirees also lost their health insurance and other benefits. Bain partners received about $50 million on their initial investment, a 100 percent gain.

“It makes me sick,” said Steve Morrow, a retired GSI steelworker, recalling what happened to his fellow workers after the Kansas City shutdown. Some top managers received bonuses from Bain, he said. “But the salaried and hourly people ended up with the shaft.”

Union appeals ignored

Union officials say they tried to work with GSI management and Bain to assure workers and retirees that they would have some benefits even if the heavily indebted company went under. But they said their appeals fell on deaf ears during and after the time Romney was running the company.

“Bain was demanding certain financial performance with no understanding of what the problems were on the ground,” said David Foster, a former steelworkers union official who negotiated labor contracts with GSI management from 1994 until the bankruptcy. He said Bain “bled the company,” withdrawing cash for dividends and management fees even as circumstances in the steel industry deteriorated.

“If I were looking for effective management of a project, a company or a country, this is exactly the kind of management I would not want to have,” Foster said of Bain.

Bain declined to comment. But individuals familiar with Bain’s strategy said that the company had a long-term interest in GSI. They said more than $100 million was invested in improving manufacturing facilities and that the company went bankrupt at a time when more than 40 other steel companies went under between 1994 and 2004.

Romney declined to comment for this story, but in public forums he has brushed aside criticism of Bain’s deals, noting that there were winners and losers in the investment portfolio.

“We didn’t take things apart and cut them off and sell them off,” Romney said in a GOP debate this fall. “We, instead, helped start businesses.”

But in 2007, during his first run for the presidency, he said he regretted extracting payments from companies that were failing: “It is one thing that if I had a chance to go back I would be more sensitive to,” he told the New York Times.

Romney and his former partners have repeatedly pointed to another, smaller investment in steel that they say offsets the GSI case and shows Bain’s overall acumen in backing companies that create jobs.

In 1994 Bain invested $18.2 million in the startup of a new steel manufacturing company in Fort Wayne, Ind., called Steel Dynamics, that is one of the industry leaders in revenue growth. Today that company reports $6.3 billion in revenue, nearly 25 times the $252.6 million reported when the company went public in 1996, according to Fred Warner, its investor relations manager. The company now employs more than 6,000 workers, and its sales growth has made it an industry star.


Click here to comment on this story »