LOS ANGELES – Wind turbines are getting really big – some with blades as long as a football field – and more powerful, often generating 50 times more electricity than the first generation of wind power machines built in the 1980s.
But scientists are also studying how to harness the wind in different ways that could help allay concerns that today’s turbines are unattractive, noisy and sometimes even dangerous.
Already in the works: Turbines that float and turbines that fly. Turbines without blades and turbines with blades fat enough to fit a double-decker bus inside.
They won’t just be on hillsides either. Some will be in the ocean, while others will be on rooftops and light poles. A few will even be in the sky.
One design was inspired by the humble bumblebee.
Sabri Sansoy, an MIT graduate and former rocket engineer, has built a 19-foot-tall prototype whose blades, rather than spin in a circle, move in a figure-eight motion like the insect’s wings. Sansoy hopes the design will generate more electricity than turbines of similar size.
“I’ve been called everything from brilliant to a nincompoop over this,” said Sansoy, whose Marina del Rey, Calif., company Green Wavelength is looking to commercialize the technology.
But “there’s a lot of people interested in this kind of thing, taking energy out of the wind,” he said.
That’s because there’s a lot of money being poured into finding ways to ease off coal-based electricity. Last year, the Department of Energy set aside a record $79 million for its wind program budget – nearly $20 million more than its previous top allotment in 1980.
At the moment, most turbines are designed to look like streamlined windmills: Blades connected to a rotor, usually mounted high on a tower to capture stronger gusts, spin like propellers in the wind. The rotor helps turn a shaft connected to a generator, which produces electricity.
But companies are coming up with innovative variations.
An Alameda, Calif., company, Makani Power Inc., is developing a kitelike contraption that generates electricity as it whips in circles in the wind. Another firm, Magenn Power Inc., has built a giant spinning blimp with generators affixed to each end. It somewhat resembles a giant inflatable hamster wheel.
Some machines could double as art installations. Poway, Calif.-based Helix Wind Corp.’s turbine looks like a spiral staircase wrapped in a white sheet. Another model, from WindTronics, evokes a large bicycle wheel – or Sauron’s eye from “The Lord of the Rings.”
Although many current installations are limited to sites with just the right mix of topography and wind speed, designers are starting to create turbines that can adapt to a wide range of terrains.
One Italian proposal involves wind turbines being built between the pillars of a bridge. Last month, turbine manufacturer Vestas said it adapted military stealth technology that can keep turbines from interfering with airport and army radar systems, potentially opening up new sites.
Turbines could also end up in the oceans as developers try to tap powerful sea breezes. Researchers say those machines could generate many times more power than land-based ones.
In March, Vestas announced a 7-megawatt offshore turbine that will be more than 600 feet tall from the blade tip to the bottom of the tower. The blades will sweep in a circle larger than the London Eye Ferris wheel.
The monstrous machines, to be made mostly with recyclable materials, will be mass produced by 2015, Vestas said.
Other developers say that land-based turbines with 300-foot blades may be ready within a decade. But some said scaling up isn’t always the way to go.
“The wind industry’s central tenet now is that bigger is better,” said John O. Dabiri, an aeronautics professor who runs Caltech’s Center for Bioinspired Engineering. “It certainly goes against conventional wisdom, but we’re taking the opposite perspective.”
On top of being difficult to design and costly to build, large turbines must sometimes be erected a mile apart to ensure good wind flow, he said. They also tend to spark complaints from residents who say they are noisy eyesores and slaughterhouses for birds and bats.
Designers are also taking cues from plants and animals – a tactic known as biomimicry.
To keep ice off turbine blades, researchers at GE are exploring how water collects on lotus leaves. Toronto-based WhalePower Corp. is testing blades modeled after humpback whales’ bumpy flippers, which allow the massive animals to make tight turns. Other studies are based on dragonflies and hawks.
But some of the newfangled models may not go far, said Nancy Rader, executive director of the California Wind Energy Association. The technology with the most longevity probably will be variations of current turbines, she said.
Subscribe to the Morning Review newsletter
Get the day’s top headlines delivered to your inbox every morning by subscribing to our newsletter