Higher revenue return good news for schools
With two months to go, estimate is $55 million over forecast
BOISE – Strong tax revenues in April could mean Idaho’s public schools will get up to a $55 million one-time boost at the end of this fiscal year on July 1 – an amount that exceeds the $47 million cut state lawmakers imposed on schools for next year.
That doesn’t reverse the unprecedented $128.5 million in cuts schools took this year. But it’s a sign that the gloomy revenue assumptions lawmakers used to slash budgets were off.
“We’re not out of the woods yet,” said Wayne Hammon, Gov. Butch Otter’s budget chief. “I’m very grateful that we set a low number and that we managed our way to it, and that we have a little extra. It’s a much better problem to have than what I had the first four years of this job, when every number seemed to be too high. It’s a much better way to run the government.”
It may not seem that way to Idaho’s school districts, however, which have to set their budgets by mid-June, before knowing how much extra money will come – or if it will come at all.
“School districts should not be setting their budgets based on whether this money will come or not, because we just don’t know,” said Luci Willits, chief of staff for state Superintendent of Schools Tom Luna. “We’ve seen positive indications about this in the past, and then it’s evaporated.”
The projection for the extra funds assumes the final two months of the fiscal year will come in on target for state tax revenues; so far, the state is $74.2 million ahead. Because of federal requirements attached to $300 million in stimulus funds Idaho accepted in past years, a certain percentage of any additional money has to go to schools.
Tom Taggart, business manager for the Lakeland School District, said, “It’s excellent news, it’s great news, but it really complicates budgeting and negotiations.”
Taggart said if the full $55 million came through, it’d mean about $800,000 for the Lakeland schools. The money is treated as a one-time appropriation, which forecloses committing it to ongoing expenses.
He said his district likely would look at building in cuts in its budget, such as furlough days, that could be reversed if the extra money showed up.
“It’s just a very complicated year with very demoralized staff, and we’re now thrown another wild card in the middle of it,” Taggart said.
Idaho lawmakers this year set a tax revenue estimate for the current year of $2.36 billion, but if the final two months come in on forecast, it’ll collect $2.43 billion. That would match the forecast for fiscal year 2011 made more than a year ago by now-retired chief state economist Mike Ferguson.
For next year, state economists projected $2.52 billion in tax revenue, a 6.9 percent increase over this year, but Otter and lawmakers budgeted for only a 3 percent increase, or $2.43 billion next year. With the 2011 revenue now on track to hit that mark, that’d mean zero growth in fiscal year 2012.
House Minority Leader John Rusche, D-Lewiston, said, “I just think that we picked numbers that were incredibly conservative.”
Sen. Shawn Keough, R-Sandpoint, vice chair of the Legislature’s joint budget committee, said, “Hindsight is always 20/20 and we still have two months to go. … I continue to believe that promising what can be delivered is better than over-promising,” which she said would lead to “disruptive” midyear cuts.