November 11, 2011 in City

Small, rural towns bear high cost of war

Hannah Van Ree And Justin Runquist Murrow News Service
 

Charlene Baldwin, the mother of Sgt. Jacob H. Demand, said the small town of Palouse, Wash., continues to remember her son, who was killed in Mosul, Iraq, two weeks before his tour was to end in September 2004.
(Full-size photo)

PALOUSE, Wash. – Sgt. Jacob H. Demand died a world away from his small hometown in Eastern Washington, gunned down in Mosul, Iraq, two weeks before his tour of duty was to end in September 2004.

But here in Palouse, population 998, the memory of Demand lives on.

“You know how usually someone only has one best friend? There are at least 15 people from Palouse that still call Jake their best friend,” said his mother, Charlene Baldwin.

About half of all enlisted recruits come from smaller towns, according to data from the U.S. Department of Defense. Recruitment rates in non-metropolitan counties are 20 percent higher than in metropolitan counties, according to the National Priorities Project, a left-leaning think tank that analyzes federal data.

A weak economy in rural areas of the country has led more young men and women to enlist, according to the authors of a national study by the Carsey Institute at the University of New Hampshire.

“Unemployment is, by far, the most dominant economic consideration linked to the propensity to enlist in the military,” said Bill Bishop, co-author of the study.

Those higher rates of recruitment have led to a disproportionate loss of life in rural communities, the Carsey study found. The 2006 study found a death rate of 24 per million among rural men and women, compared with a death rate of 15 per million in urban areas.

In Washington and Idaho, those deaths have echoed in small towns like Wilbur, Craigmont, Granger, White Swan, and Colville.

In St. Anthony, a town of 3,542 in eastern Idaho, residents lined the sidewalks and waved white flags during the 2005 funeral procession for Lance Cpl. Dustin Vincent Birch, who died when a roadside bomb hit his vehicle in the Anbar province of Iraq.

“We were just deluged with people offering their support,” said his father, Paul Birch. “It wasn’t just our loss. It was a loss for the whole town. St. Anthony lost one of its own.”

After Army Staff Sgt. Wyatt Andrew Goldsmith died in Afghanistan in July, more than 800 people attended his funeral in Colville, population 4,673.

“It was kind of staggering, really,” said John Goldsmith, Andrew’s father. “I was actually kind of stunned.”

Challenges in coming home

Surviving veterans often face unique challenges when they return to rural communities, experts say, such as a lack of resources to help them reintegrate.

“Most commonly, veterans need help reintegrating back into life, whether that be as a student, spouse, or parent,” said Rhonda Allenger, of the Palouse River Counseling Center in Pullman, who has treated veterans for depression and post-traumatic stress disorder. “A lot of life has gone on while they have been gone.”

Veterans in rural areas often experience worse mental health problems and cost more to treat, studies from the American Psychiatric Association conclude.

Distance is just one of the challenges.

In North Idaho, veterans are funneled into VA services in Spokane. Those in Nez Perce, Lewis and Clearwater counties use the VA Medical Center in Walla Walla.

Idaho’s only VA hospital is in Boise, although it has clinics in other cities. To help vets in rural areas, the Boise VA has begun using new “Telehealth” technology, said Dr. Beth Fassig, a psychologist there.

“We’re helping patients get set up with the right equipment so we can have both audio and visual connection with them,” Fassig said.

In Washington, 13 rural counties do not have veterans’ centers to treat post-traumatic stress disorder and related problems, according to the state’s Department of Veterans Affairs. In those areas, the VA contracts with local counselors. As in Idaho, counselors in Washington have begun to use televised links to connect veterans with medical care.

Experts say isolation can make the transition home particularly difficult to veterans.

“When you have been in the military and exposed to war, you really are changed forever,” said Thomas Schumacher, program director of PTSD counseling for the Washington state Department of Veterans Affairs. “You may dress like a civilian, but you are never really a civilian again totally.”

Remembering the fallen

Rural families of soldiers bear a burden as well, but many say that small towns are especially supportive.

In Rochester, Wash., the family of Army Cpl. Christopher Nelson witnessed that support. Nelson, 22, was killed by a suicide bomber in Iraq in 2007. He was delivering candy and toys to children when he died.

The 22-year-old left behind his wife, Angela, his high school sweetheart. After his death, American flags filled the town and a billboard featured Nelson.

“Everyone in town knew of Chris or someone in the family. Everyone came together in support,” said Julie Marquez, Chris’ sister-in-law.

In Palouse, Jacob Demand is still remembered seven years after his death. His photograph is displayed in the local school. The town has a memorial plaque dedicated in his honor.

“I’ll never forget when during the Palouse Days parade, the grain truck drivers from around the area paraded through the town, each with a sign with Jake’s name on it as they passed us,” said his mother.

Marine Cpl. Joseph Phillip Bier died on Dec. 7, 2005, when a roadside bomb detonated during combat operations in Ramadi, Anbar province, Iraq. The 22-year-old lived in Chehalis before he joined the Marines.

At Bier’s funeral, the local church was “packed wall-to-wall,” according to his father, Wayne Bier.

“People in small towns have feelings of nationalism, patriotism, family,” Wayne Bier said. “There are few places where you can get a stronger feeling of brotherhood today.”

The Murrow News Service provides local, regional and statewide stories reported and written by journalism students at the Edward R. Murrow College of Communication at Washington State University.

Get stories like this in a free daily email


Please keep it civil. Don't post comments that are obscene, defamatory, threatening, off-topic, an infringement of copyright or an invasion of privacy. Read our forum standards and community guidelines.

You must be logged in to post comments. Please log in here or click the comment box below for options.

comments powered by Disqus