November 15, 2011 in City

Judge allows execution

Inmate says injection could be cruel
Rebecca Boone Associated Press

BOISE – A federal judge has refused to postpone the execution of an Idaho inmate slated to be put to death this Friday.

U.S. Magistrate Judge Ronald Bush said in a 43-page ruling Monday that he would not grant a stay of execution to Paul Ezra Rhoades.

Rhoades, who was convicted of killing three people and sentenced to death for two of the murders, is scheduled to die by lethal injection Friday.

He is suing the state in federal court, contending that Idaho’s execution method can be easily botched and so amounts to cruel and unusual punishment, and he asked Bush to put his execution on hold while the lawsuit works through the courts.

State attorneys countered that Idaho’s lethal injection process closely mirrors lethal injection protocol in other states that has already been upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court. The process relies on three drugs administered through IV: an anesthetic meant to make the condemned inmate deeply unconscious, followed by a paralytic that will make the inmate unable to draw breath, and finally a drug that will stop the inmate’s heart.

The judge said that he agreed that the execution, if done incorrectly, could leave Rhoades in agony as he dies. But he also said the Idaho Department of Correction has done enough to safeguard against that error.

Bush went on to say that Idaho isn’t required to implement a one-drug execution – which essentially overdoses an inmate with an anesthetic – as Rhoades had wanted. The judge said that’s because Rhoades didn’t make a “more certain showing” that the existing three-drug protocol raises a substantial risk of serious harm.

“The State of Idaho has an interest in seeing that its laws are enforced, and further delay will not meet that interest,” Bush wrote.

The ruling appears to clear the way for Rhoades’ execution, scheduled for Friday at 8 a.m. MST. If the execution happens, it will be Idaho’s first in 17 years and the only one in the last half-century to happen without the consent of the condemned inmate.

Rhoades was given two death sentences for the sexual assault and murder of Idaho Falls teacher Susan Michelbacher, 34, whose bullet-ridden body was found in March 1987, and two death sentences for the first-degree murder and kidnapping of Stacy Dawn Baldwin, 21, a Blackfoot, Idaho, convenience store clerk who was shot to death in February 1987.

Rhoades was also sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole after pleading guilty to the March 1987 shooting death of Nolan Haddon, 20, a Blackfoot man who worked at an Idaho Falls convenience store.

© Copyright 2011 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Thoughts and opinions on this story? Click here to comment >>

Get stories like this in a free daily email