August 31, 2012 in Nation/World

Federal court halts Texas’ voter ID law

Second ruling in week against Lone Star state
David G. Savage McClatchy-Tribune
 

WASHINGTON – A federal court has ruled for the first time that a strict photo identification law discriminates against poor and minority voters in violation of the Voting Rights Act, barring Texas from enforcing its new requirement at polling places this fall.

The decision puts a national spotlight on an election law issue that sharply divides Republicans and Democrats and one that could have an effect on who wins a close contest.

It also highlights the North-South divide on voting laws. While Northern and Western states are free to change their election laws and tighten the rules for voting, much of the South remains subject to the Voting Rights Act because of past discrimination. Before making changes, Southern officials must convince the Justice Department or a federal court that the new rules will not harm racial minorities.

Twice this week, Texas failed that test. On Tuesday, a federal court struck down the state’s new maps for congressional and legislative districts on the grounds they undercut the voting power of Latinos and African-Americans.

In Thursday’s decision, a separate three-judge panel focused on how a new photo identification rule would affect the tens of thousands of registered voters in Texas who are poor, do not drive and do not have cars in their households.

In the past, Texas voters who had registered in advance could bring to the polls voter cards sent to them by the state. The new law, passed last year, would instead require a current government-issued photo identification card, such as a driver’s license, a U.S. passport, a U.S. military ID card or a license to carry a concealed handgun.

Texas’ lawyers called this requirement a “minor inconvenience.” The vast majority of Texans already had such cards in their wallets or purses, and with birth certificates and Social Security cards in hand, voters could obtain free photo ID cards at an office of the Texas Department of Public Safety, they said.

But the judges said that about a third of Texas counties did not have a Department of Public Safety office. And those offices are not open on weekends. Moreover, it costs about $22 to obtain a copy of a birth certificate, they said.

“Even the most committed citizen, we think, would agree that a 200- to 250-mile round trip – especially for would-be voters having no driver’s license – constitutes a substantial burden on the right to vote,” Judge David Tatel said in the unanimous opinion.


There are 10 comments on this story. Click here to view comments >>

Get stories like this in a free daily email