May 31, 2012 in City
Trial begins in 1992 robbery, homicide
The lengthy trial of a convicted robber began this week after DNA linked the registered sex offender to a fake beard worn during the killing of a Spokane Valley business owner in 1992.
Patrick K. Gibson, 60, is charged with first-degree murder in connection with the Nov. 7, 1992, slaying of Brian Cole, who – according to witnesses – was robbed at gunpoint by a man who also indicated he was willing to hurt Cole’s wife, who was in a wheelchair.
The crime went unsolved for 19 years before DNA from a fake beard left at the East Sprague crime scene prompted detectives to arrest Gibson, who has convictions in Oregon, Nevada and California for kidnapping, rape, robbery and bank robbery.
Deputy Spokane County Prosecutor Tony Hazel said he expects the bench trial before Superior Court Judge Tari Eitzen to last 2 1/2 weeks, based on the number of witnesses and amount of evidence. Hazel and Jack Driscoll, chief deputy criminal prosecutor, are handling the case against Gibson, who is being defended by Victoria Blumhorst and John Whaley.
On the witness stand, Deputy David Trautman testified that he was the first person to respond to the call at Cole’s Traditions in Oak.
“I went inside the store, contacted the victims and made sure the bad guy was gone,” Trautman said. “Brian Cole was lying behind the counter … right inside the main entrance. He was bleeding out of the right side of his head.
“He was talking with me. He was concerned whether he would be all right,” Trautman said. Trautman said he did the best he could to get a description of the attacker and to relay that information to other deputies. Trautman later was able to speak with Michele Cole, who said a man came into the store and said it was a robbery. Her husband responded, “You’re kidding.”
Brian Cole told the robber that his customers paid by check or bank card and the store kept no cash on hand. The robber then demanded wallets from the Coles, Trautman said, reading from his 20-year-old report.
At one point, Brian Cole asked the suspect, “You are going to hurt a handicapped lady?” referring to his wife, who was in an electric wheelchair. The suspect replied, “Yeah I just might,” Trautman said.
Soon after, Brian Cole jumped the suspect, who produced a .22 caliber pistol and shot Cole twice in the head and once in the chest. He died about 90 minutes later on the operating table at Spokane Valley Medical Center.
Michele Cole told Trautman that she remembered the gunman as being clean shaven except for a fake beard that covered the lower portion of his face.
It was the beard, according to court records, that eventually helped detectives charge Gibson with the crime based on a DNA match.
Now-retired sheriff’s Detective Mark Henderson, who was the lead detective in the case, said that at the time detectives relied much more on fingerprints and hair fibers to match suspects.
The case went unsolved despite being featured on “America’s Most Wanted” in January 1993, according to newspaper archives.
Detectives reviewed the case in December 2010 and learned that the fake beard had never been submitted for DNA testing. In April 2011, the results matched Gibson, who had his DNA profile in a national database from a previous conviction.
Detectives Lyle Johnston and Mike Drapeau traveled last year to Stanwood, Wash., and arrested Gibson. The detectives also learned from FBI agents that Gibson wore fake beards while committing other robberies for which he was later convicted.