Arrow-right Camera


Ryan faces tough crowd at AARP talk

Sat., Sept. 22, 2012

Medicare proposal yields mixed reply

Mitt Romney’s vice presidential nominee Paul Ryan was booed at the annual AARP convention after saying their Republican administration would repeal the nation’s new health care law as the best way to save Medicare.

Just five minutes into his talk at the gathering of the powerful 50-and-older lobby on Friday, the architect of the Republican proposal to change Medicare for the next generation of seniors was repeatedly interrupted as he criticized President Barack Obama’s health care law.

“The first step to a stronger Medicare is to repeal Obamacare, because it represents the worst of both worlds,” Ryan said as the crowd in New Orleans booed audibly.

“I had a feeling there’d be mixed reaction,” Ryan acknowledged, pausing briefly. “So let me get into it.”

But Ryan only drew further objections from the crowd as he provided a more detailed explanation for his criticism of the new health care law.

When he suggested that Obama was cutting $716 billion from Medicare over the next decade to pay for the costs of insuring more Americans under the health care law, those gathered booed. Ryan’s own budget relies on using the same savings from Medicare, but he applies it to paying down the nation’s deficit.

Ryan also elicited a round of objections when he suggested that the health care law “weakens Medicare for today’s seniors and puts it at risk for the next generation.” The health care law reduces spending on Medicare payments to providers, which officials have said would add eight years to the program’s solvency, though it is still expected to run out of money by 2024.

Seniors have provided a healthy constituency for Republicans, with promises of low taxes and conservative views on many social issues, but the Romney-Ryan approach to Medicare has drawn sharp divisions. Polls show most Americans want to keep Medicare as is.

Under the Republican approach to Medicare, the next generation of seniors, those now 55 years old and younger, would be given a fixed stipend to buy health insurance.

While Republicans say health costs would be driven down by forcing competition among insurers offering policies, critics say there is no guarantee the voucher from the government – or premium support – would be worth enough for seniors who still want to opt for Medicare. Nonpartisan analysts say seniors could pay as much as $2,000 a year out of pocket to make up the difference. The Republican proposal requires that the stipend be set at the lowest-priced insurance policy, which may not be Medicare.

“We respect you enough to level with you,” Ryan told the crowd as he began the 30-minute address, and he did draw some applause as he outlined the approach a Republican would take.

As he often does, Ryan mentioned that his mother, Betty, a senior on Medicare from Florida, was campaigning with him Friday, and that his goal is to preserve the popular health safety net not only for this generation, but that of his three young children.

The talk by the GOP vice presidential nominee followed a video appearance by Obama.

Both candidates made the appearance amid a day of campaigning, with Ryan headed next to the senior-rich swing state of Florida.


There are six comments on this story »