Arrow-right Camera


Sat., Oct. 19, 2013, midnight

Protect the Initiative Act

Pro: Our state is littered with examples of citizens being denied the right to vote

I support Initiative 517 because I am a strong believer in initiative rights, which Washington has had for over a century. Our right to initiative and petition our government is the most important tool we have to push back when government does things we don’t like.

I-517’s primary policy change is guaranteeing you the right to vote on qualified initiatives.

In a unanimous ruling, the Washington Supreme Court in 2005 rejected an effort by special interest groups to stop the people from voting on a qualified initiative. Their reason: “Because ballot measures are often used to express popular will and to send a message to elected representatives, pre-election review unduly infringes on free speech.”

Despite this clear ruling, dozens of citizen-sponsored initiatives – liberal and conservative – were blocked from a public vote in recent years even though local citizens followed all the rules.

In King County, after local citizens qualified an initiative to reduce the size of the King County Council, the county sued to block the vote.

In Vancouver, after local citizens qualified an initiative for the ballot, the City Council refused to let the people vote.

In Spokane, local citizens qualified an initiative for the ballot but a lawsuit blocked the people from voting.

In Bellingham, Monroe, Mukilteo, Redmond, Longview and Wenatchee, local citizens sponsored initiatives letting the voters decide on red-light ticketing cameras in their communities. In every instance, the city or out-of-state red-light camera company sued the citizens to block the vote. Their lawyers said only politicians were capable of discussing and deciding on ticketing cameras.

They said the topic wasn’t “proper” for the voters to decide.

In my view, what’s not proper is having the government telling us they know best. To me, what’s not proper is the government deciding what issues we, the people, can and can’t express our opinion on.

Unfortunately, this same thing has happened repeatedly to state and local initiatives.

In every one of these efforts, citizens followed all the rules, yet each of them was hit with expensive, needless obstruction because state law doesn’t clearly mandate a vote on qualified initiatives. I-517 fixes that. With I-517, if the initiative qualifies, then the voters decide.

The Legislature is never going to protect the citizens’ initiative process. That’s why Initiative 517 is so important, and why I’m supporting it.

I-517 also gives everyone greater access to the initiative process. Since 1912, the number of signatures required to qualify for the ballot has skyrocketed almost tenfold, while the time to manually collect signatures has remained the same at six months. Oregon allows two years; Idaho a year and a half. I-517 simply matches the national average, which is one year to collect signatures.

And I-517 does one other thing that’s really important: It stops initiative opponents from bullying people who want to sign an initiative petition. Bullying – on sidewalks, walkways and other public places – is becoming far too common, and I-517 puts a stop to it. I-517 makes it safe for you to exercise your right to participate and vote. I-517 supports democracy, promotes respectful speech, and stops bullying.

But what really moved me about I-517 – what convinced me to support it and speak out for it – is its guarantee that the people get to vote on qualified initiatives. With I-517’s protections, future generations will have the chance to have their voices heard at the state and local level.

Please join me and the hundreds of thousands of your fellow citizens who signed I-517 petitions in voting yes on I-517. Thank you.

Barbara Smith is a longtime Spokane resident and is volunteering as treasurer for the YES on 517 campaign. For more information on I-517, go to the website

There are four comments on this story »


Memorial Day Weekend Wild Card 5.27-5.29.17

Enjoy your weekend. If you're so inclined: The National Moment of Remembrance encourages all Americans to pause wherever they are at 3 p.m. local time on Memorial Day for a ...

The week that was…

On tonight’s “Idaho Reports” on Idaho Public Television, co-host Melissa Davlin interviews BSU professors Justin Vaughn and John Freemuth about federal issues from Craters of the Moon to the federal ...

Royal Columns rock climbing area reopened

CLIMBING -- The Royal Columns climbing area on the Oak Creek Wildlife Area in Yakima County has been reopened since being closed in late April after a basalt column collapsed, ...

When someone in Spokane has a far-away look

What do you suppose that person is thinking about? Here are 10 guesses. 10. Restoring a vintage car. 9. A backyard garden. 8. A romance that simply cannot happen. 7. ...