Nearly all of the 60 cabin owners whose Priest Lake cabin sites were auctioned by the state of Idaho on Thursday were able to purchase the properties at the appraised value, with no competitive bidding.
For most, the auction provided relief after years of controversy about the appropriate rent the state would charge cabin owners. While the land under their cabins was owned by the state, they built and owned their cabins.
There were tears of joy and high-fives from relieved cabin owners. There also was some continuing anger from those who resented the long process they’ve endured dealing with the state over their family cabin sites, and disputed the values the state set for the ground, which served as the minimum bidding price. That ranged from $200,000 to $665,000, for the land only.
The take for Idaho’s public school endowment on Thursday: $26.9 million.
Idaho long has rented the lakefront lots to people who build and own cabins on them, but the state has struggled to charge the constitutionally required market-rate rents. It has sharply upped the rents in recent years, pricing out some longtime cabin owners. The auction is part of the state’s attempt to get out of the cabin-site renting business. Just two of the sites drew competitive bidding; on one of those, the current lessee didn’t bid and the competition was between two prospective new owners. The state made more than $123,000 above the appraised value as a result. The other one that saw multiple bids came when a competitor bid up the price but the current lessee outbid him; that one went $9,000 over the appraisal.
All but two of the other cabin sites sold to the current lessees; in one exception, the current lessees had arranged to sell their cabin to a buyer who bid in their place. The other site drew no bids and went unsold.
Billy Symmes accompanied his beaming mother out of the contract-signing room after finalizing the purchase of the ground under their family cabin, which they’ve had since 1994. “Getting to hold onto the cabin is great – the process, no comment,” he said.
Denny Christenson, president of the Priest Lake State Lessees Association, said the process has been “confusing and frustrating” for cabin owners. At the end of the process, however, he was relieved to have ownership of the ground under his longtime family cabin.
“It feels good. It’s going to be a while to sink in,” said Christenson, moments after signing contracts to take ownership of the property. “Twenty-three years as a lessee and having a landlord – now we don’t have a landlord.”
He added with a chuckle. “Now, we have a mortgage.”
The process has moved in fits and starts. All of the cabin sites auctioned Thursday were included in earlier land exchanges, but the state Land Board abruptly canceled all exchanges last December.
“It totally changed course at the end of last year, so there was lots of concern that the state would not follow through with the auction,” Christenson said.
The 60 sites were divided into four groups, with a group auctioned every two hours at the Coeur d’Alene Resort. Christenson waited through much of the day before his cabin lot came up for auction in the 5 p.m. batch.
After each batch of auctions, cabin owners exchanged hugs and slaps on the back. “I know my gut’s been churning, and I’m not even in this round,” one said. “Taxes will be cheaper than the lease,” said another.
Steven Hubbs, 68, successfully bid the appraised value, $200,000, for the ground under the lake cabin he’s had for the past 15 years.
“It seems fair,” he said. “I think a lot of the older people that have owned cabins on the lake for a long time, I think they’re at a disadvantage – I don’t think they’re being treated fairly. But for people who bought recently, I think it’s fair.”
Don Morris of Chewelah came to watch the auction out of curiosity; his Priest Lake cabin is on a deeded site that he owns, so he’s not affected, but he used to own one on a state lease. He was among a crowd of more than 250 at Thursday’s auction.
“I’ve been on the lake since I was 15 years old,” Morris said. He said he was “a little surprised” that there wasn’t more competitive bidding. “I kind of thought there might be more investors come in and try to snag some of these properties,” he said. The real estate company handling the auction, Corbett Bottles, “certainly did a good job” advertising it, Morris said.
When he bought his first cabin on state-leased land in 1972, it had a 99-year lease and the rent was $100 a year. That soon changed; the lease term dropped to 10 years, and the rent started going up. “I could just see that the price was going to get too much,” Morris said, so when he had a chance to buy a cabin on land he could own outright instead, he did it.
Asked if it was worth the drive to watch the auction Thursday, Morris said, “As soon as it’s done, I’m going to the lake.”
Subscribe to the Morning Review newsletter
Get the day’s top headlines delivered to your inbox every morning by subscribing to our newsletter