Sports

Tim Dahlberg: NCAA may not be bumbling idiots after all

Former Eastern Illinois safety Adrian Arrington would have to pay for treatment of head injuries by himself. (Associated Press)
Former Eastern Illinois safety Adrian Arrington would have to pay for treatment of head injuries by himself. (Associated Press)

Two down, one big one to go.

And with it a growing realization that maybe the people running the NCAA aren’t the bumbling idiots everyone has been making them out to be.

The NCAA’s agreement Tuesday to create a $70 million fund to diagnose concussions and brain injuries does more than just give some former and current athletes a bit of peace of mind – if no real money. It also extricates the organization from another serious threat to its existence, one that could have potentially bankrupted it if everyone who ever suffered a concussion playing college sports were somehow able to cash in.

Coupled with a $20 million settlement on a video games lawsuit announced on the eve of Ed O’Bannon’s landmark trial in June, the NCAA not only deftly avoided two major threats, but did so relatively cheaply. Unlike the $765 million concussion settlement the NFL agreed to, the NCAA will not pay players for any damage caused to their brains and will not pay to treat them even if such damage is diagnosed.

That quickly drew criticism from a leading activist for player rights, who said the settlement is just another reason players need a union to represent them on health and safety issues.

“This preliminary concussion settlement isn’t even on the radar of what should be a fair agreement,” said Ramogi Huma, head of the College Athletes Players Association. “It offers no resources for players who are struggling with the effects of traumatic brain injury. Not one penny.”

It was good enough, though, for the attorneys representing current and former players in the class action lawsuit. They’ll get their payday from the lawsuit, even if athletes get little more than some tests to see if their brains are scrambled and a referral to the proper doctors for treatment – assuming they have their own insurance or some other way of paying for it.

The NCAA, meanwhile, gets rid of a huge potential liability – at only a fraction of the cost of the $770 million it gets annually for hosting college basketball’s big tournament.

“To put it in context, they have over a half a billion dollars in reserves they’re doing nothing with. It just sits in the bank,” Huma said. “Some of that money could be used to help players in need but the settlement doesn’t do that.”

That’s no real surprise, because the major focus of the NCAA over the years hasn’t been player safety or athlete rights. Rather, it’s been enriching those who run the game.

The only reason some of that has changed is the pressure brought by Huma’s group – which campaigned for a union organizing vote among Northwestern football players that shook the NCAA to the core – and a series of lawsuits on behalf of player rights. That includes the concussion lawsuit, which is a wide-ranging class action suit that covers all men and women who participated in contact sports at more than 1,000 schools.

Settling that suit was huge, but it may not even be the biggest win for the NCAA this summer. If it can somehow prevail in the O’Bannon antitrust litigation – something most legal experts don’t see happening – it could remove perhaps the biggest threat of all: Having to pay players for their services.

But even if the NCAA loses the decision expected in the next few weeks, it will not necessarily be the Armageddon for college sports. That’s true even if colleges are eventually forced to share some of the huge money they’re bringing in for basketball and football with players once they leave school.

The NCAA has already said it will appeal to highest court.

There are still other lawsuits to deal with, other problems that remain. That can’t be avoided when you’re trying to pretend that big time college sports are amateur when in reality everyone is getting paid but the athletes themselves.

Suddenly, though, a summer that threatened to spell disaster for the NCAA at every turn seems to be turning out not so bad after all.



Click here to comment on this story »





Blogs

UI men’s basketball: Vandals at Lumberjacks

Big Sky Men's Basketball Idaho Vandals (14-9, 6-4) at Northern Arizona Lumberjacks (3-18, 1-9) Saturday, Feb. 6, 1 p.m. | Walkup Skydome, Flagstaff, Ariz. Watch: Online: WatchBigSky.com Outlook: NAU Up ...


TGIF Wild Card — 2.5.16

I find myself eyeing my garden spot in the back yard every morning when I first wake up. I have plans for some changes there. But I did much of ...


The week that was…

Tonight’s “Idaho Reports” rounds up the happenings of the fourth week of this year’s legislative session, from Medicaid expansion to tax cuts. Melissa Davlin interviews House Health & Welfare Chairman ...


5 education reads found in the last 7 days

More education writing. This week covers imposter syndrome, (especially among high-achieving students of color) the five folk looking to run the Washington Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction (what a ...





Sections


Profile

Contact the Spokesman

Main switchboard:
(509) 459-5000
Customer service:
(800) 338-8801
Newsroom:
(509) 459-5400
(800) 789-0029
Back to Spokesman Mobile