May 15, 2014 in Idaho

Idaho gay marriage ruling stayed by appeals court

By The Spokesman-Review
 
Kathy Plonka photoBuy this photo

“I just can’t break what I believe,” said ordained minister Don Knapp as he stood in front of the Hitching Post Wedding Chapel in Coeur d’Alene on Wednesday. Knapp says the chapel will refuse to officiate weddings for same-sex couples.
(Full-size photo)

Idaho residents planning to gather at courthouses across the state to celebrate same-sex marriages saw their plans put on hold Thursday by a federal appeals court.

Idaho’s gay marriage ban was overturned Tuesday when U.S. Magistrate Judge Candy Dale ruled it unconstitutional. Dale said Idaho must begin issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples starting this morning, but the state filed emergency motions seeking a delay while they appealed the ruling.

On Thursday afternoon, the 9th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals issued a temporary stay, putting a hold on gay marriages in Idaho while it considers the state’s motions. The court didn’t signal how long it would take; for now, everything’s on hold.

Of the four lesbian couples who successfully sued to overturn Idaho’s ban on same-sex marriage, two had hoped to get marriage licenses first thing this morning; the other two were looking forward to having their legal marriages from other states recognized in Idaho.

“As hard and as heart-wrenching as this ‘temporary stay’ is for all those people who were planning to finally get married tomorrow, this may be the best thing that the court could have done,” Sue Latta, the lead plaintiff in the case, told The Spokesman-Review. “If they had had a knee-jerk reaction, we probably would have gotten a ‘stay pending appeal,’ which will take many months, but they didn’t do that. They are going to take a hard look at all the new case law that has been generated … and whether it seems like the state will ultimately be successful, and I believe that they are going to deny the stay.”

Said Latta, “We are going to win because all we are asking for is to be treated like everyone else, and that is not an unreasonable thing to ask for.”

Latta and wife Traci Ehlers, of Boise, have been together for 10 years, and were legally married in California in 2008.

Idaho Gov. Butch Otter welcomed the temporary stay on Thursday, saying it will help avoid “chaos and uncertainty.”

“Meanwhile, I am proceeding with an aggressive challenge in the appellate court,” Otter said in a statement. “I’m hopeful for a better outcome, but in any event I am committed to defending our Constitution and the will of Idaho voters.”

Otter also brought in an additional attorney for the appeal, Monte N. Stewart, the founding president of the Utah-based Marriage Law Foundation and former U.S. Attorney for Nevada; Stewart now is a Boise attorney.

Stewart has worked to defend bans on same-sex marriage in at least eight states, including Utah, where he was co-chairman of the group that campaigned for the ballot measure imposing Utah’s now-challenged constitutional ban; several of his writings were cited in Otter’s earlier arguments in the Idaho case.

Idaho’s county clerks participated in an online training session Thursday afternoon to go over procedures to comply with the federal court decision legalizing same-sex marriage. Just before the session started, the news of the 9th Circuit delay arrived.

“They were pretty well ready,” said Dan Chadwick, executive director of the Idaho Association of Counties. “If the injunction goes into effect, the counties are ready to perform their duty.”

North Idaho Unitarian Universalist Fellowship minister Tracy Springberry had planned to be at the Kootenai County Courthouse this morning to perform same-sex marriages for free for anyone who wanted them, and was disappointed to hear of the delay. “I guess we won’t do that,” she said with a sigh.

Springberry said Unitarian Universalists have been performing same-sex marriage ceremonies since the ‘70s. “We really believe, in my tradition, that people who are in committed, loving relationships need to have those recognized by their communities and their societies and have legal protections, and that everyone should be treated equally and respectfully,” she said. “For me, it’s a very important religious issue.”

Springberry said she’d put the word out that she’d be at the courthouse, following the lead of other Unitarian Universalist ministers in other states when their states legalized same-sex marriage.

“I’m sad,” she said. “But I kind of feel like this is sort of the way this goes. It’ll be a bumpy ride. I think it’ll probably pass eventually.”

So far, gay marriage is legal in 17 states and the District of Columbia.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Check back at www.spokesman.com for updates.


There are 106 comments on this story. Click here to view comments >>

Get stories like this in a free daily email