Edgar Steele, the North Idaho attorney who first gained notoriety for defending Aryan Nations leader Richard Butler and later was imprisoned for plotting to kill his wife, is dead. He was 69.
The federal prison in Victorville, California, has listed him as deceased Sept. 4, and officials have notified Steele’s wife, Cyndi Steele, according to news releases.
Information regarding the manner of Steele’s death is pending. He reportedly had been in declining health for weeks.
Cyndi Steele never believed that her husband was involved in a murder-for-hire scheme to kill her and her mother.
But a Boise jury convicted Steele of four felonies for paying his handyman in silver to kill Steele’s wife and mother-in-law with a car bomb.
Steele called his wife after his arrest and told her to say the voice on the FBI recordings was not his, which led to a conviction for victim tampering.
A federal judge sentenced Steele to 50 years in prison for the crimes.
Edgar Steele’s background includes a history of association with North Idaho white supremacists. Aryan Nations founder Richard Butler hired the Sandpoint attorney in 2000 to defend the group from a lawsuit filed by the Southern Poverty Law Center on behalf of a woman and her son who were shot at outside Butler’s Hayden Lake compound.
Although Steele lost the court battle and the $6.3 million jury award bankrupted the group and shut down the compound, he quickly rose to prominence in the extremist movement, calling himself an “attorney for the damned.”
Some of his supporters are already crafting conspiracy theories about Steele’s death. The website www.free-edgar-steele.com put up a post claiming that Steele was murdered by the federal government and that his arrest and conviction were “orchestrated … in an attempt to silence his politically incorrect thought, research and commentary.”
The website also alleges that Cyndi Steele was notified of her husband’s death by a mortuary, not by prison authorities.
Cyndi Steele, who operates a horse farm on the couple’s property, filed for divorce in June 2000, alleging her husband “misrepresented his marital status and eligibility” in online dating profiles “with the sole intention of meeting women” in San Mateo, California, where he maintained a law office. But the case was dismissed two months later and the couple remained married.
When Steele took over the Aryan Nations’ defense, he said it wasn’t because he shared Butler’s beliefs but because he believed the case was about free speech. He sued The Spokesman-Review over an article he said implied otherwise. The Idaho Supreme Court dismissed the lawsuit in 2003.
Subscribe to the Morning Review newsletter
Get the day's top headlines delivered to your inbox every morning by subscribing to our newsletter