Arrow-right Camera
News >  Family

Ask Dr. Universe: Did dinosaurs actually roar?

This artist rendering from the Natural History Museum of Utah shows an ankylosaur, a squat plant-eater that was covered in bony armor from its spiky head to its clubbed tail, that has been unveiled at the museum in Salt Lake City. The ankylosaur, Latin name Akainacephalus johnsoni, roamed southern Utah on four legs about 76 million years ago, during the late Cretaceous Period. (Natural History Museum of Utah / Natural History Museum of Utah)
This artist rendering from the Natural History Museum of Utah shows an ankylosaur, a squat plant-eater that was covered in bony armor from its spiky head to its clubbed tail, that has been unveiled at the museum in Salt Lake City. The ankylosaur, Latin name Akainacephalus johnsoni, roamed southern Utah on four legs about 76 million years ago, during the late Cretaceous Period. (Natural History Museum of Utah / Natural History Museum of Utah)

Q: Did dinosaurs actually roar? – Susan, Spokane

Dear Susan,

In the movies, we often hear dinosaurs let out big, scary sounds. If you’ve ever played with toy dinosaurs, maybe you’ve also made your little Tyrannosaurus rex roar.

While dinosaurs have a reputation for roaring, I wasn’t entirely certain whether or not they actually did so in real life. I asked my friend Cynthia Faux, who’s a Washington State University professor.

“It’s impossible to say for sure,” Faux said. “But we can speculate.”

Faux is really curious about dinosaurs, especially those descendants of two-legged dinosaurs that soar through the sky today: birds.

Examining an animal’s voice box might give us clues about what kind of sound it made. There are lots of birds on our planet, and they all have different tweets, caws and chirps. Of course, a dinosaur’s voice box would have been much bigger than a bird’s voice box.

Sometimes when we want to learn about life in the past, we examine fossils. Fossils are preserved traces of plants and animals. Some scientists even study poop fossils to find out what animals ate. But not all parts of an animal can be traced through fossils. Some voice boxes are made up of soft tissue.

This soft tissue breaks down over time, which makes it hard to figure out exactly what kind of voice box a dinosaur used to make their sounds.

Scientists who conducted some of the most recent research into dinosaur sounds have found that the creatures actually might have cooed or boomed. In fact, that sound may been similar to the kinds of noises today’s emus or ostriches make, Faux said.

Roaring is also more of a mammal thing, Faux added. Lions, tigers and bears are all predators that roar – but they aren’t roaring all the time. When they do roar, it’s often to show their dominance or to scare away another animal.

After all, making a lot of sound when you approach your prey isn’t the brightest idea. It works much better to quietly sneak up on your prey, so they don’t know what’s coming.

There may have been some other ways dinosaurs communicated, too. Some dinosaurs may have displayed their feathers. Yes, some dinosaurs had feathers. They may have used them as a way to send messages to those around them – perhaps as a defense or to attract a mate.

Sauropods, plant-eating, four-legged dinosaurs that usually had long necks, were as big as houses and made a lot of noise just by walking around. Perhaps their stomping sent a message to those around them. Some dinosaurs may have communicated in a way similar to alligators. By creating vibrations in the water, they could let creatures around them know they are frightened and might strike.

Alligators, birds and all kinds of animals make interesting sounds on our planet these days. Can you hear any animal sounds in your neighborhood? Can you guess what animal is making the sounds you hear? Tell us about it at Dr.Universe@wsu.edu.

Sincerely,

Dr. Universe

Ask Dr. Universe is a project from Washington State University. Submit a question of your own at http://askDrUniverse.wsu. edu/ask.


Subscribe to the Morning Review newsletter

Get the day’s top headlines delivered to your inbox every morning by subscribing to our newsletter

There was a problem subscribing you to the newsletter. Double check your email and try again, or email webteam@spokesman.com

You have been successfully subscribed!


Top stories in Family

At the Vet’s: Treat with love

Veterinary medicine is expensive, and the doctors must be able to lay out options for clients, give them choices and prices. Dr. Greg Benoit is a small business owner, and he’s got to keep things running and make sure everyone understands that even if something can be done medically, it’s always the owner’s call whether to go ahead. Shaming will not work and is in no one’s best interest.