SEATTLE – It’s hard to know for sure quite yet what the Mariners’ trade of catcher Mike Zunino to the Tampa Bay Rays means in the big picture, except for one thing:
Jerry is going to be Jerry.
I speak, of course, of general manager Jerry Dipoto, whose “reimagining” of the Mariners’ roster (to use his recent phrase) is guaranteed to be aggressive and multifaceted. Because that’s how he rolls.
Typically, Dipoto has jumped the market with the first significant deal of the winter. The trade will send Zunino, outfielder Guillermo Heredia and minor-league pitcher Michael Plassmeyer to the Rays for outfielder Mallex Smith and minor-league outfielder Jake Fraley.
Despite the flurry of excitement, the Mariners are not likely to “tear it down to the studs” (to use another fond Dipoto expression) by trading all their coveted young and controllable players on the rise, namely Mitch Haniger, Edwin Diaz, Marco Gonzales and James Paxton.
But also don’t expect the Mariners to resemble the ballclub that finished the season on Sept. 30 with their 89th win, a deceptive total that doesn’t reflect the sense of decline in the second half. Paxton, for instance, is highly likely to be dealt because the market for pitchers with his potential and relatively low salary is intense. Such a trade could jump-start the Mariners’ reimagination.
Zunino once fell in the same category as that quartet – young, dripping with promise and close to untouchable. But typical of so many high draft picks and golden prospects of recent Mariners vintage, it never quite panned out.
Certainly not for lack of effort, either. No one cared more, or worked harder than Zunino, the No. 3 overall pick in 2012 who showed enough flashes of brilliance to perpetually tease that a breakout was coming. That was most prevalent in 2017 when he put up a .281/.361/.589 stat line, with 24 homers, over the final 95 games.
With his defensive prowess, those are superstar numbers if sustained. But Zunino never found his groove this past season, finishing with a .201 average and a 40-percent strikeout rate. The stark reality is, that showing was more in tune with his career arc than the breakout in ’17.
But the possibility still exists, of course, that Zunino will find himself in Tampa and gain that consistent stardom. It exists because that seems like such a common Mariners outcome, but also because Zunino is 27 years old and with great tools and legitimate power that will play better at Tropicana Field. I’ve always felt Zunino was on the verge of figuring things out, and maybe a change of scenery will do the trick.
Heredia, meanwhile, was one of those players who was exposed the more playing time he got. But he’s a standout defender and a perfectly serviceable fourth outfielder.
From the Mariners’ end, this is one of those trades that seems like the first shoe dropping. Mallex Smith is a quality player, one who the Mariners, in retrospect, would have been better off hanging onto when they swung a deal for him with Atlanta in 2017. Instead, Seattle was just a half-hour way station for Smith before the M’s shipped him on to Tampa Bay (with pitcher Ryan Yarbrough, a 16-game winner for the Rays in 2018) for Drew Smyly, who never threw a pitch for the Mariners.
Smith, meanwhile, had a breakout year in 2018 at age 25, hitting .296 with 40 stolen bases and a WAR that was 3.5 (via Baseball Reference) and 3.4 (via FanGraphs). Though certainly not a power hitter (two homers), Smith led the American League with 10 triples and had more extra-base hits (39 to 38) and just a slightly lower slugging percentage (.406 to .410) than Zunino.
The Mariners also got Fraley, a left-handed outfielder who was a supplemental second-round pick in the 2016 draft out of LSU. He had a standout year in Class-A ball, hitting .347/.415/. 547 in 66 games in 2018. Fraley is 23, and the Mariners need all the high-upside young prospects they can get.
Smith will, presumably, take over center field, which leads to the obvious question of what happens to Dee Gordon? Will he be traded, too? Does he move to second base, Robinson Cano to first, and Ryon Healy traded? Does Gordon move to short and Jean Segura is traded? And, oh yeah, who is going to catch?
All are intriguing questions. Watching how it unfolds, how the pieces fit together, and how closely Dipoto’s reimagination is really a thinly disguised rebuild – and how much that rebuild resembles a teardown – will make this a fascinating winter for the Mariners.
And now it has officially begun.
Subscribe to the sports newsletter
Get the day’s top sports headlines and breaking news delivered to your inbox by subscribing here.