Arrow-right Camera
News >  World

Recriminations fly after fire roars through Brazilian museum

UPDATED: Mon., Sept. 3, 2018, 9:56 p.m.

A National Museum worker organizes pieces rescued from the museum after an overnight fire in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Monday, Sept. 3, 2018. (Silvia Izquierdo / Associated Press)
A National Museum worker organizes pieces rescued from the museum after an overnight fire in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Monday, Sept. 3, 2018. (Silvia Izquierdo / Associated Press)

RIO DE JANEIRO – Firefighters dug through the burned-out hulk of Brazil’s National Museum on Monday, a day after fire roared through the building, as the country mourned the irreplaceable treasures lost and pointed fingers over who was to blame.

People watch as flames engulf the 200-year-old National Museum of Brazil, in Rio de Janeiro, Sunday, Sept. 2, 2018. (Leo Correa / Associated Press)
People watch as flames engulf the 200-year-old National Museum of Brazil, in Rio de Janeiro, Sunday, Sept. 2, 2018. (Leo Correa / Associated Press)

The museum held Latin America’s largest collection of historical artifacts, and officials suggested that the damage could be catastrophic, with most objects in the main building probably lost.

For many in Brazil, the state of the 200-year-old natural history museum quickly became a metaphor for what they see as the gutting of Brazilian culture and life during years of corruption, economic collapse and poor governance.

“It’s a crime that the museum was allowed to get to this shape,” said Laura Albuquerque, a 29-year-old dance teacher who was in a crowd protesting outside the gates. “What happened isn’t just regrettable, it’s devastating, and politicians are responsible for it.”

Students and National Museum personnel protest outside the museum which suffered an overnight fire in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Monday, Sept. 3, 2018. The signs in Portuguese read: "The museum is ours," and "The museum is not merchandise." Recriminations flew over who was responsible for a huge fire that destroyed of at least part of Latin America’s largest collection of historical artifacts and documents. (Silvia Izquierdo / Associated Press)
Students and National Museum personnel protest outside the museum which suffered an overnight fire in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Monday, Sept. 3, 2018. The signs in Portuguese read: "The museum is ours," and "The museum is not merchandise." Recriminations flew over who was responsible for a huge fire that destroyed of at least part of Latin America’s largest collection of historical artifacts and documents. (Silvia Izquierdo / Associated Press)

The cause of the fire that broke out Sunday night was not known. Federal police will investigate since the museum was part of the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro. But protesters, commentators and museum directors themselves said years of government neglect had left the museum so underfunded that its staff had turn to crowdfunding sites to open exhibitions.

Luiz Fernando Dias Duarte, the museum’s deputy director, criticized authorities for starving the museum of vital funding while spending lavishly on stadiums to host the World Cup in 2014.

“The money spent on each one of those stadiums – a quarter of that would have been enough to make this museum safe and resplendent,” he said in an interview in front of the still-smoldering building aired on Brazilian television.

Roberto Leher, rector of the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, said it was well known that the building was vulnerable to fire and in need of extensive repairs. Duarte said he was in the habit of unplugging everything in his office at night because of the risk.

Civil defense authorities were concerned that internal walls and the roof could collapse further, so officials had to wait to conduct a full accounting of losses.

Duarte said that anything held in the main building was likely destroyed. The collection of 20 million cultural and historical items included pieces that belonged to the royal family and a painting by the Brazilian artist Candido Portinari.

The National Museum stands gutted after an overnight fire in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Monday, Sept. 3, 2018. (Mario Lobao / Associated Press)
The National Museum stands gutted after an overnight fire in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Monday, Sept. 3, 2018. (Mario Lobao / Associated Press)

The museum, which was once home to the royal family, also housed extensive paleontological, anthropological and biological specimens. It was home to a skull called Luzia that was among the oldest fossils ever found in the Americas. It also held a Torah and an Egyptian mummy and the largest meteorite ever discovered in Brazil – one of the few objects that officials could confirm had survived.

Brazil has struggled to emerge from a two-year recession and seen its political and corporate elite jailed in Latin America’s largest corruption investigation. The country has been riven with deep political divisions following the impeachment and removal of former President Dilma Rousseff.

The protesters gathered outside the museum gates tried several times to push into the site, demanding to see the damage and calling on the government to rebuild. Police held the crowd back with pepper spray, tear gas and batons.

“This fire is what Brazilian politicians are doing to the people,” said Rosana Hollanda, a 35-year-old high school history teacher, who was crying. “They’re burning our history, and they’re burning our dreams.”

Students and National Museum employees protest outside the institution after it was gutted by an overnight fire in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Monday, Sept. 3, 2018. (Silvia Izquierdo / Associated Press)
Students and National Museum employees protest outside the institution after it was gutted by an overnight fire in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Monday, Sept. 3, 2018. (Silvia Izquierdo / Associated Press)

Signs of disrepair were evident: The fencing was dilapidated, stonework was cracked and lawns appeared untended.

As the museum was preparing to celebrate its bicentennial in June, its budget had fallen from around $130,000 in 2013 to around $84,000 last year, the Folha de S.Paulo newspaper reported in May.

In a sign of how strapped the museum was, when a termite infestation last year forced the closure of room that house a 13-yard-long dinosaur skeleton, officials turned to crowdfunding to raise the money to reopen the room.

The institution had recently secured approval for nearly $5 million for a planned renovation, including an upgrade of the fire-prevention system, officials said.

“Look at the irony. The money is now there, but we ran out of time,” museum Director Alexander Kellner told reporters at the scene.

National Museum Director Alexander Kellner talks with his personnel after an overnight fire at the museum in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Monday, Sept. 3, 2018. The esteemed museum houses artifacts from Egypt, Greco-Roman art and some of the first fossils found in Brazil. (Silvia Izquierdo / Associated Press)
National Museum Director Alexander Kellner talks with his personnel after an overnight fire at the museum in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Monday, Sept. 3, 2018. The esteemed museum houses artifacts from Egypt, Greco-Roman art and some of the first fossils found in Brazil. (Silvia Izquierdo / Associated Press)

Education Minister Rossieli Soares said $2.4 million would be given to the university immediately to deal with the damage to the building.

President Michel Temer announced Monday that private and public banks, as well as mining giant Vale and state-run oil company Petrobras, have agreed to help rebuild the museum and reconstitute its collections. French President Emmanuel Macron offered in a tweet to send experts to help rebuild the museum.

Brazil is in the midst of a national election campaign and some candidates on the left seized on the fire as an example of the disastrous effects of budget cuts implemented by Temer’s government. The Folha data showed that cuts to the museum’s budget began under the previous left-wing government.

Fire department spokesman Roberto Robadey said firefighters got off to a slow start because the two fire hydrants closest to the museum did not work. Instead, trucks had to gather water from a nearby lake.

There were fire extinguishers in the museum, but it was not clear if there were sprinklers, which are problematic for museums because water can damage objects, Kellner said.

Marcus Guidoti, a doctoral candidate in zoology who had visited the museum to study insect specimens, said the neglect dates back years.

“Let this free us from the ignorance that fails to appreciate culture, science and our national identity,” he wrote on Twitter.


Subscribe to the Morning Review newsletter

Get the day’s top headlines delivered to your inbox every morning by subscribing to our newsletter

There was a problem subscribing you to the newsletter. Double check your email and try again, or email webteam@spokesman.com

You have been successfully subscribed!


Top stories in World

Saudi prosecutor seeks death penalty in Khashoggi killing

UPDATED: 10:19 a.m.

updated  Saudi Arabia’s top prosecutor said Thursday he’s seeking the death penalty for five suspects charged with ordering and carrying out the killing of dissident Saudi writer Jamal Khashoggi at the kingdom’s consulate in Istanbul.