The draft evasion trial of famous football coach William H. “Lone Star” Dietz ended in a hung jury after 20 hours of deliberation.
More than a dozen ballots were taken, and most of the jurors were in favor of acquittal. In the end, however, four of the 12 stood firm for conviction, and the jury entered the courtroom with a request for discharge.
Those who stood for acquittal cited the testimony of the U.S. Marine officers from Mare Island, who said they had approved Dietz’s draft questionnaire. Dietz was working at the time as the football coach of the Mare Island training camp. Jurors also believed Dietz when he testified that he believed he was telling the truth about his Native American heritage when he signed the draft questionnaire. Whether he truly had Native American blood or not was not the point – the key question was whether he believed he did when he filled out the questionnaire.
Those who stood for conviction did not believe that Dietz was telling the truth about his heritage. They cited the fact that he claimed to speak the Sioux language, but he only knew one word. Also, he had shown little or no brotherly affection to the woman he claimed was his sister, Sally Eagle Horse, who lived on the Pine Ridge
The jury was discharged after giving no verdict, but this was not the end of the Lone Star Dietz legal drama. New developments would arise within 24 hours.
Subscribe to the Morning Review newsletter
Get the day’s top headlines delivered to your inbox every morning by subscribing to our newsletter.