Arrow-right Camera
The Spokesman-Review Newspaper

The Spokesman-Review Newspaper The Spokesman-Review

Spokane, Washington  Est. May 19, 1883
Partly Cloudy Night 49° Partly Cloudy

Eye On Boise

Crapo calls on Trump to withdraw comments about federal judge Curiel

Idaho GOP Sen. Mike Crapo, attacked yesterday by Democratic challenger Jerry Sturgill for backing presumptive GOP nominee Donald Trump despite Trump’s statements that a federal judge presiding over a fraud case involving Trump University can’t be fair because of the judge’s Mexican heritage, is calling on Trump to retract his comments.

Here’s my full story from

Idaho Sen. Crapo calls on Trump to withdraw judge comments

By Betsy Z. Russell


BOISE – Idaho GOP Sen. Mike Crapo, pressed by Democratic challenger Jerry Sturgill to disavow presumptive GOP nominee Donald Trump’s statements that a federal judge presiding over a fraud case involving Trump University can’t be fair because of the judge’s Mexican heritage, is now calling on Trump to retract his comments.

"Donald Trump may have his reasons for questioning how his case is being handled. But that should stop well short of attacking the judge in the case regarding his ethnic background. He should withdraw his remarks,” Crapo said in a statement issued late Monday night.

Sturgill, a Boise businessman who is making his first run for office, issued a press release Monday morning calling on Crapo to reject Trump’s “overtly racist” remarks about Judge Gonzalo Curiel, an Indiana native whose parents were immigrants from Mexico. Trump said Curiel had “an absolute conflict” in presiding over his case because he was “of Mexican heritage.” He’s since doubled down on the comments, saying a Muslim judge also would be biased in his civil fraud case because of his campaign statements about Muslims.

Trump’s comments have drawn sharp criticisms from many in his own party. Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., said, “This is the most un-American thing from a politician since Joe McCarthy. … If anybody was looking for an off-ramp, this is probably it. There’ll come a time when the love of country will trump hatred of Hillary.”


Sturgill, in his news release, said, “What Donald Trump said about Judge Curiel shocks the conscience and he should be ashamed. … Is this behavior what Sen. Crapo supports? Is Sen. Crapo proud of Trump’s comments?”

Crapo has been circumspect about Trump’s candidacy, saying consistently that he doesn’t endorse in primaries but will support his party’s nominee. He referred briefly to the presidential race in his comments at the state GOP convention over the weekend, according to the Twin Falls Times-News, saying it's a contest between two ideas of America, as a "caretaker society" or an "opportunity society."  

A month ago, Crapo told KIFI-TV Local News 8 in Idaho Falls, “We know our presumptive nominee is Donald Trump, and I will accept that outcome and I’m going to support and try my hardest to help him get elected. I think he needs to clarify a number of his positions, and I think that you will see him start to do that as we move forward.”

Trump has been unfazed by the criticism, which has come from everyone from U.S. House Speaker Paul Ryan to New Hampshire GOP Sen. Kelly Ayotte, who called the comments “offensive and wrong” – but, like Crapo, didn’t withdraw their support for his campaign. Trump said on Fox News, "All I want to do is figure out why I'm being treated unfairly by a judge. And a lot of people agree with it."

Sturgill said, “I am asking Sen. Crapo to stand for common decency and publicly call on Donald Trump to apologize to Judge Curiel and his family. To fail to do so will be inconsistent with our Idaho values.”

On Tuesday, Sturgill said of Crapo’s statement, “I’m glad that my press release had that effect.” He said, “It’s just the right thing, for Sen. Crapo to call Trump on the racist, bigoted comments he’s making, and all the other hateful things that have come from the Trump bully pulpit. I think all the Republicans should withdraw their support. I don’t know how they can endorse, I don’t know how they can endorse him.”

Top Idaho GOP office-holders have been unenthusiastic about Trump; Ted Cruz won Idaho’s primary. According to the Times-News, 1st District Congressman Raul Labrador told the GOP convention on Saturday, “I jokingly say Trump wasn't even in my top 16. But he's my nominee and I'll support him.”

A day earlier, Gov. Butch Otter told the GOP crowd that he voted for John Kasich for president, but it’s time to come together for presumptive nominee Donald Trump, saying, “Trump will tower over Hillary.” 

None of the other members of Idaho’s congressional delegation had any immediate comment Tuesday on Crapo’s statement or Trump’s comments; Suzanne Wrasse, spokeswoman for Sen. Jim Risch, said he “will be voting for Donald Trump based on his concern over who will be appointed the next Supreme Court justice. Beyond that, he will not give interviews or comment on Trump.”

Late Tuesday, Trump issued a lengthy statement, saying in part, “It is unfortunate that my comments have been misconstrued as a categorical attack against people of Mexican heritage. … I am friends with and employ thousands of people of Mexican and Hispanic descent.” But he continued to criticize the judge and maintained he would win the Trump University case. “While this lawsuit should have been dismissed, it is now scheduled for trial in November,” Trump said. “I do not intend to comment on this matter any further.”

Betsy Z. Russell
Betsy Z. Russell joined The Spokesman-Review in 1991. She currently is a reporter in the Boise Bureau covering Idaho state government and politics, and other news from Idaho's state capital.

Follow Betsy online: