If a risky Procter & Gamble experiment proves successful, coupon-clippers who spend Sundays with a newspaper and scissors may need a new weekend pastime - along with a new money-saving tactic.
Procter & Gamble Co. - the consumer products giant that makes hundreds of staples including Tide detergent, Pampers diapers and Folgers coffee - will eliminate coupons for its products in three trial cities in western New York. Instead of coupons, P&G says, it will lower everyday prices.
P&G direct-mail and newspaper coupons in Buffalo, Rochester and Syracuse, N.Y., will end Feb. 1. Grocers there will honor valid P&G coupons from national women’s magazines and old newspapers. But P&G expects to eliminate 98 percent of coupons in the three cities.
If the experiment reduces P&G’s overhead without hurting sales, the company may end coupons elsewhere. And if P&G can pull it off, experts predict other consumer-goods companies could follow.
Those are big ifs.
“It has a chance to work, but no one knows for sure,” said Michael Johnson, marketing professor at the University of Michigan. “The Krafts and General Foods are going to be watching this closely. So will consumers.”
Others predict the experiment will fail miserably. P&G has misjudged consumers’ infatuation with coupons, said Gary Stibel, a former P&G manager who runs a Connecticut consulting company.
“This is one of the few occasions that Procter is absolutely wrong,” Stibel said. “Consumers love coupons. … I think the consumer will punish Procter in the test market, and their competitors may also.”
For now, coupon-clippers needn’t worry that the number of coupons they receive will drop. The average American sees about 1,000 coupons a month, according to P&G studies.
But the coupon craze, which reached new heights in the late ‘80s when supermarkets overdosed on coupon promotions, doubling and even tripling the discounts, is showing signs of decline.
In fact, P&G research indicates that coupon redemption rates fell from 3.5 percent in 1983 to 2 percent in 1994. P&G has cut spending on coupons in half since 1991.
More families have two spouses with full-time jobs, and parents aren’t willing to spend hours hunting coupons when savings amount to spare change, experts say. Also, the warehouse revolution has led many people to shop at wholesale clubs, where coupons are usually invalid. Shoppers rely on bulk discounts instead.
Consumer-goods producers have aggressively plowed a path toward coupon-free shopping because coupons are costly to print and distribute. U.S. companies spent $6.5 billion last year to pass out coupons - and more than half of that went to administrative overhead.
“Coupons are an inefficient promotion,” said Greg Rossiter, P&G spokesman at the Cincinnati headquarters. “We can eliminate coupons and pass the savings on to consumers.”
xxxx Company products These are some of the consumer products manufactured by Procter & Gamble: Cosmetics: Max Factor, Cover Girl. Fruit juices: Hawaiian Punch, Sunny Delight. Tissues: Charmin, Puffs. Coffee: Folgers. Cooking oil: Crisco. Detergent: Tide. Diapers: Pampers.
Local journalism is essential.
Give directly to The Spokesman-Review's Northwest Passages community forums series -- which helps to offset the costs of several reporter and editor positions at the newspaper -- by using the easy options below. Gifts processed in this system are not tax deductible, but are predominately used to help meet the local financial requirements needed to receive national matching-grant funds.
Subscribe now to get breaking news alerts in your email inbox
Get breaking news delivered to your inbox as it happens.