YAKIMA – Had the fatal confrontation with Otto Zehm been a mock scenario used in training, Spokane police Officer Karl F. Thompson Jr. would have failed, a use-of-force expert testified Monday.
Robert Bragg, who directs use-of-force training for all police recruits at Washington’s police academy, said Thompson violated his training and had no reason to immediately begin striking Otto Zehm with a baton on March 18, 2006.
“Given the lack of reasoning for the use of force, everything that follows doesn’t serve a legitimate law enforcement purpose,” Bragg told U.S. District Court jurors.
As the trial enters its second week, the witness list for today includes Assistant Chief Jim Nicks, who initially insisted Spokane police officers did nothing wrong but later in interviews with the FBI became the highest-ranking city official to acknowledge apparent use-of-force violations and a faulty police investigation into the confrontation.
Nicks’ testimony, however, may be delayed.
According to Spokane police spokeswoman Officer Jennifer DeRuwe, Nicks recently “experienced a medical event.” DeRuwe would not elaborate.
Two federal prosecutors said Monday they were unaware of a potential medical problem, and defense attorney Carl Oreskovich said only that he was aware that Nicks was ill.
Nicks was acting chief the night of the incident more than 5 1/2 years ago. He publicly stated that Zehm “lunged” and “attacked” Thompson in a north Spokane convenience store, but told a federal grand jury that Thompson violated department policy. U.S. District Court Judge Fred Van Sickle previously ruled that Nicks cannot testify about that breach of policy.
In the courtroom Monday, other witnesses included Allison Smith, one of two young women who made the initial call to police that led to the confrontation. She was only asked about what she saw going on inside the store and described Thompson running in and immediately striking Zehm.
Leroy Colvin and Michael Dahl were also inside the store that night and both said they heard Thompson tell Zehm to “drop the pop.” Colvin said he could not see what was happening when Thompson gave the command, but Dahl said Zehm was already on his back holding a bottle of soda. “He seemed like he was protecting himself more than anything,” Dahl said.
Colvin said what portions of the confrontation he could see included Thompson taking a “full swing” at Zehm, who was holding a bottle “across his face in protection mode.”
Zehm, a 36-year-old janitor with schizophrenia, stopped breathing inside the store after being beaten, shocked with Tasers and hog-tied. He died two days later.
Attorneys again sparred over the admission of evidence Monday while outside the presence of the jury.
Sparking the clash was defense attorney Steven Lamberson’s cross-examination of Colvin, who was asked whether he knew Thompson was investigating an attempted robbery.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Aine Ahmed objected and told Van Sickle that the defense had opened the door to allowing questions suggesting that Zehm had not committed a crime, which he hadn’t. Van Sickle had previously barred any reference to Zehm’s innocence.
Lamberson “left the impression that dirties up Mr. Zehm as being a robbery suspect,” Ahmed said.
“I think the term ‘robbery’ has taken us down the wrong path,” Lamberson conceded. “That term will not be used again.”
Van Sickle took it a step further. He agreed with Ahmed’s suggestion to strike from the record any questions or answers regarding lay witness testimony about a possible robbery attempt and wants the attorneys to craft what’s known as a “curative instruction” for the jury to disregard the earlier “robbery” references.
Local journalism is essential.
Give directly to The Spokesman-Review's Northwest Passages community forums series -- which helps to offset the costs of several reporter and editor positions at the newspaper -- by using the easy options below. Gifts processed in this system are not tax deductible, but are predominately used to help meet the local financial requirements needed to receive national matching-grant funds.
Subscribe to the Coronavirus newsletter
Get the day’s latest Coronavirus news delivered to your inbox by subscribing to our newsletter.