Arrow-right Camera
The Spokesman-Review Newspaper

The Spokesman-Review Newspaper The Spokesman-Review

Spokane, Washington  Est. May 19, 1883
Partly Cloudy Day 67° Partly Cloudy
News >  Nation/World

Almonds get roasted in debate over California water use

Almond grower Bob Weimer inspects almond trees in his orchard near Atwater, Calif. As California cities and towns move to mandatory water cutbacks in the fourth year of extreme drought, the state’s $6.5 billion almond crop has claimed the spotlight as “the poster child of all things bad in water” in the country’s top agriculture state. At 1 gallon per almond, California’s almond crop is now consuming about 10 percent of all the water that Californians are using in the drought. (AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli)
Almond grower Bob Weimer inspects almond trees in his orchard near Atwater, Calif. As California cities and towns move to mandatory water cutbacks in the fourth year of extreme drought, the state’s $6.5 billion almond crop has claimed the spotlight as “the poster child of all things bad in water” in the country’s top agriculture state. At 1 gallon per almond, California’s almond crop is now consuming about 10 percent of all the water that Californians are using in the drought. (AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli)
By Ellen Knickmeyer Associted Press
SAN FRANCISCO — California almonds are becoming one of the world’s favorite snacks and creating a multibillion-dollar bonanza for agricultural investors. But the crop extracts a staggering price from the land, consuming more water than all the showering, dish-washing and other indoor household water use of California’s 39 million people. As California enters its fourth year of drought and imposes the first mandatory statewide water cutbacks on cities and towns, the $6.5 billion almond crop is helping drive a sharp debate about water use, agricultural interests and how both affect the state’s giant economy. Almonds have claimed the spotlight as “the poster child of all things bad in water,” almond grower Bob Weimer said. People around the world are eating over 1,000 percent more California almonds than they did just a decade ago, and last year almonds became the top export crop in the nation’s top agriculture state. China’s booming middle class is driving much of the demand. That strong Asia market is producing up to 30 percent returns for investors, prompting agri-businesses to expand almond planting in the state by two-thirds in the past decade. The crop has come to be dominated by global corporations and investment funds. Rows of almond trees now cover nearly 1 million acres in California, many of them on previously virgin hillsides or in pastures or desert with little rain or local water. Since each tiny nut requires a gallon of water, almonds are consuming 1.07 trillion gallons annually in the state, one-fifth more than California families use indoors. So when Gov. Jerry Brown ordered cities and towns this month to cut their water consumption by 25 percent but exempted farms, almonds got toasted in the public heat that followed. “Drought villains?” the Los Angeles Times asked this month. A Sacramento TV station referred to “almond-shaming.” National Public Radio called almond farms “a rogue’s gallery” of water users. Now almond farmers and investors are on the defensive. “The tomato growers use a lot more water than we do. You should go after those guys,” said Ryon Paton, a global real-estate developer and principal of Trinitas Partners. Paton’s online literature tells investors to think of his newly planted almond orchards in Stanislaus County as “the classic Silicon Valley startup, except we have nothing to do with technology.” He regularly has to deny rumors — including from fellow almond farmers — that celebrities such as Oprah Winfrey and Condoleezza Rice are among the investors drawn to his almond fund. California growers provide 80 percent of the global supply of almonds. In China, where the number of middle-class households has doubled since 2006, consumers see almonds as a healthy snack and regard American food in general as less contaminated than products from elsewhere. California almonds are a popular bagged treat in China’s convenience stores and supermarkets and a must-have item in holiday gift baskets. As big a global money-maker as California’s agriculture is, though, it’s little more than a blip in the state’s economy. And that’s driving the debate on water use. In all, agriculture uses 80 percent of the water that Californians draw from groundwater and surface supplies but produces just 1.5 percent of the state’s gross domestic product, noted Christopher Thornberg, an economist who has served as an economic adviser to state agencies. Other top almond producers include Stewart and Lynda Resnik, the politically influential Beverly Hills billionaires behind Fiji bottled water, Pom pomegranate juice and a Central Valley almond and pistachio operation that they say is one of the world’s largest. The TIAA-CREF retirement fund also boasts of its California almond operation as one of the world’s biggest. Smaller almond farmers view the newer, bigger almond investors skeptically. “They shouldn’t be growing almonds or walnuts in those areas,” including parts of the state that are naturally too dry and too cold for almond trees, said Paul Wenger, head of the state Farm Bureau and an almond and walnut grower on land near Modesto that’s been in his family for a century. Almonds aren’t even the biggest sponges when it comes to water-thirsty crops in semi-arid California — that would be the state’s million acres of alfalfa, which go to feed livestock. Unlike the row crops they’re displacing, the new almond trees require water year round. The big almond growers “are saying you’ve got to deliver us water. We don’t care about this. We don’t care about that,” said Weimer, the Merced County grower of almonds and other crops. His wells have gone from 40 feet deep in 1977 to 90 or 100 feet this year, as farmers and other users draw from the underground reservoirs. “We’ve crossed an interesting boundary here,” Weimer said. Continuing strong prices have some California growers rushing to plant still more trees. In a U.S. Department of Agriculture survey for 2014, 77 percent of state almond farmers polled said they intended to put in new almond acreage despite the drought. The governor and his cabinet secretaries defend almonds as a high-value crop. “We’re going to try to maximize all beneficial uses, not pick one we like better than the others,” said Felicia Marcus, head of the state Water Resources Control Board. Any talk of curbing almond growing by big investment firms “really just gets to be kind of un-American,” said Wenger, the head of the state Farm Bureau. Even though he dislikes some almond investors, Wenger said, “it’s a free country. And they have a right to do whatever they can.”
The Spokesman-Review Newspaper

Local journalism is essential.

Give directly to The Spokesman-Review's Northwest Passages community forums series -- which helps to offset the costs of several reporter and editor positions at the newspaper -- by using the easy options below. Gifts processed in this system are not tax deductible, but are predominately used to help meet the local financial requirements needed to receive national matching-grant funds.

Active Person

Subscribe now to get breaking news alerts in your email inbox

Get breaking news delivered to your inbox as it happens.