A cardboard cutout on display at the Ada County Republicans’ booth at the Western Idaho Fair this weekend earned harsh criticism online, prompting volunteers to take down the display within hours.
The life-size poster depicts Donald Trump yelling as he holds former opponent Hillary Clinton in a headlock. It reportedly first appeared at the booth Friday evening. By Saturday afternoon, it was no longer on display but still located at the GOP fair booth. Anyone wanting to take a photo with the cutout could do so outside of the booth, said Anita Leatham, a precinct committeewoman who volunteered at the booth Sunday.
Comments criticizing the cutout continued to pour in on social media Sunday.
Diana Lachiondo, a Democratic candidate for Ada County commissioner, posted a photo of the cutout on her Facebook page around 2 p.m. Saturday. She called the display “juvenile and pretty un-classy, not to mention that it seems to promote violence against women.” By Sunday afternoon, her post had been shared more than 650 times and garnered nearly 400 comments decrying the cutout as “tasteless,” “vile,” “disgusting” and “shameful.”
“I’m proud to have friends of all political stripes and I don’t believe the Republicans I know would support this. It really is beneath them and the party of Lincoln,” Lachiondo wrote.
Sharon Ullman, the Republican nominee for a different commissioner seat, agreed. Ullman said she reached out “behind the scenes” on Friday night and Saturday to ask fellow Ada County Republicans to remove the display. Photos of fair attendees with the cutout were deleted from the Ada County Republicans’ Facebook page, as well.
“It’s not the image that I think the Ada County Republicans or the Idaho Republicans or I want to project,” Ullman said Sunday. “The concept of violence bothers me in any context. It’s not what we stand for.”
Many of the commenters on Lachiondo’s post echoed Ullman – including other Idaho Republicans.
“I want to thank the Republican candidates … who did speak out about this cartoon display,” wrote Steve Smylie, a West Ada School Board trustee and former state lawmaker. “Some thought it a joke, perhaps, but at a public place where the object is to put the party in a good light, recruit supporters, and make friends, this doesn’t cut it.”
Lachiondo said she worried how fairgoers would explain the “joke” to children. And further, she wondered, why rehash the 2016 election? Lachiondo said doing so is a disservice to voters who are concerned with local issues like growth and Idaho’s response to the opioid crisis.
“(Voters) just don’t have time for this kind of nonsense,” she said.
Ullman said she hoped the brief display and ensuing discussion didn’t leave a bad taste in voters’ mouths.
“I would hope that this one decision (to display the cutout) doesn’t turn the public against our party, our candidates or our volunteers,” she said.
It wasn’t clear Sunday who decided to erect the cutout, or later made the final call to take it down. Early that afternoon, it sat tucked away under a table in a cardboard envelope addressed to Ryan Davidson, chairman of the Ada County Republicans.
Leatham said the cutout distracted from the Republicans’ goal of registering Idahoans to vote.
Still, she said, in the 20 minutes she had spent at the booth, at least one person had asked to take a photo with it. A handful more had posed with another life-sized cutout of Trump still on display, smiling while holding two thumbs up.
Local journalism is essential.
Give directly to The Spokesman-Review's Northwest Passages community forums series -- which helps to offset the costs of several reporter and editor positions at the newspaper -- by using the easy options below. Gifts processed in this system are not tax deductible, but are predominately used to help meet the local financial requirements needed to receive national matching-grant funds.
Subscribe to the Coronavirus newsletter
Get the day’s latest Coronavirus news delivered to your inbox by subscribing to our newsletter.