Arrow-right Camera
The Spokesman-Review Newspaper
Spokane, Washington  Est. May 19, 1883

Lawsuit: Care home forced disabled man to fight to the death

By Margaret Stafford Associated Press

KANSAS CITY, Mo. – A developmentally disabled Missouri man was forced to fight another man for the “amusement” of people who ran the private care home where he lived and was left to die in a bathtub from injuries he suffered in the clash, his mother has alleged in a lawsuit.

Carolyn Summers, the mother of Carl DeBrodie, also alleges in the lawsuit filed Tuesday that government agencies responsible for her son didn’t provide required care and didn’t check on DeBrodie for months. DeBrodie’s body was found in April 2017 encased in concrete in a container inside a storage area, months after he went missing.

No one has been arrested or charged in DeBrodie’s death.

According to the lawsuit, DeBrodie and another resident of Second Chance Homes in Fulton were taken in October or November of 2016 to the home of two Second Chance employees, where they were forced to do manual labor, sleep on the basement floor and fight each other. DeBrodie suffered serious injuries in the fight, including at least six broken ribs.

That night, DeBrodie was found screaming and convulsing on the basement floor. He was bleeding from his nose and mouth when he was placed in a bathtub with the shower running, but no emergency medical help was called before DeBrodie died, according to the lawsuit. The body was likely left in the bathtub for two or three days before it was hidden in the storage area, the lawsuit alleges.

DeBrodie was not reported missing until April 17, 2017, and his body was found April 24. The body was so badly decomposed that investigators determined he had been dead for months.

Callaway County Prosecuting Attorney Chris Wilson said he’s not yet ready to comment on a criminal investigation in the case.

“I continue to work with the federal prosecutors on that front and have agreed not to act unilaterally and potentially jeopardize their work” Wilson in a statement published Wednesday by KMIZ-TV.

Wilson was not available to expand on that statement Thursday or comment to the Associated Press on when or if charges might be filed.

Summer’s attorney, Rudy Viet, told The Fulton Sun that the Missouri Attorney General and Callaway County prosecutors provided the new details in the case and that he’s “very confident” the information is accurate.

The lawsuit names 18 defendants, including Second Chance Homes – a private facility that received state and county funds – the Missouri Department of Mental Health, the Callaway County Public Administrator’s Office, Callaway County Special Services and several individuals working for those agencies. Callaway County is about 150 miles east of Kansas City, Missouri.

Employees of the agencies were legally required to meet with DeBrodie every month and fill out reports to indicate that he was healthy and being properly cared for. The lawsuit contends those face-to-face meetings weren’t held for several months and that the employees filed fraudulent reports saying they had seen DeBrodie, even though they had been told he wasn’t feeling well and were aware of reports that the home’s operators verbally and physically abused him.

The lawsuit also says caseworkers and employees of Second Chance Homes prevented Summers and others from visiting DeBrodie in the months preceding his death.

A spokeswoman for the Missouri Department of Mental Health hasn’t responded to a message Thursday seeking comment on the lawsuit.

No hearing date has been set. The family is seeking a jury trial.