A Bonner County man with a history of challenging local government and, in his words, “confronting socialism” may force changes to the way Sandpoint’s 25-bed hospital has been run for nearly 40 years.
Bonner General Hospital is in discussions with the board of a public taxing district to transfer ownership of some of its clinics in response to a finding from the Idaho Attorney General’s office that payments between the two were in violation of the state constitution.
Daniel Rose, who is the only elected member of the taxing district that has no ties to the private nonprofit hospital, has threatened legal action and made accusations of criminal conduct against hospital officials.
“It is a misuse of funds, they can look at it the way they want,” Rose said.
Ford Elsaesser, a Sandpoint attorney who serves as chairman of the Bonner General board of directors, disputed misuse of funds. He pointed to decades of audits and the past approvals of public funding that pays a small portion of the hospital’s maintenance costs each year.
That’s necessary for a rural hospital such as Bonner General that must compete for business with major health care centers in Spokane and Coeur d’Alene, he said.
“There’s no cloud over the operations,” Elsaesser said. “We’re extremely proud of what the hospital has accomplished. We have a town of 10,000 people that has a full-service hospital.”
Rose was elected to the board of the public hospital district in 2017. He finished last among five people running for five open seats, thus he won one of the seats. The other members of the taxing district also serve on Bonner General’s board of directors. Rose does not, and began voting against the taxing district’s funding of Bonner General.
He then filed a whistleblower complaint, which prompted the Idaho attorney general’s staff to investigate. The attorney general’s office determined the arrangement violated state laws and the state constitution.
The hospital district isn’t the first public agency Rose has targeted in North Idaho. In 2017, he and his wife filed more than 100 public records requests with the Lake Pend Oreille School District, according to the Bonner County Daily Bee. The records were sought as voters were asked to support a $17 million school district levy.
Months later, multiple candidates filed to run for the school board in what some Republicans saw as an effort to pack the board with adherents of the far-right fringes of the GOP. Those candidates lost their elections, but Rose won what amounted to an uncontested seat on the board of the public hospital district.
Rose’s current tussle regarding hospital funding has been reported on Redoubt News, a website aimed at conservatives who have migrated to the region in search of political refuge or to prepare for an apocalypse.
But Rose and his attorney, Sean Smith, said adherence to the law, not ideology, is prompting their effort to change the funding practices at Bonner General.
“We don’t want our government, whoever it is, picking who the winners are,” Smith said. “This is literally confiscating people’s wealth, property taxes, and giving it to somebody else.”
Rose said he’s “well-recognized in the community for, how do we say, confronting socialism.” In a January 2018 letter to the editor of the Sandpoint Reader alternative weekly newspaper, Rose accused educational leaders and media personalities in the community of being socialist.
Steve Youngdahl retired from the Lake Pend Oreille School Board in 2017, and said Rose routinely would show up at meetings and question spending decisions. Rather than work with school officials on issues he saw as a problem, Youngdahl said, Rose rebuffed any overtures to cooperate.
“He insisted on having an adversarial relationship,” said Youngdahl, who also identified as a Republican. “He turned down every offer. He’s not really in search of a solution.”
At issue in the Bonner General case are millions of dollars of annual Bonner County property taxes captured by the public hospital district and then transferred to the private nonprofit Bonner General. The arrangement was agreed to in the early 1980s.
However, the Idaho Constitution prohibits such tax revenues from being used to support private organizations, which would include Bonner General as a nonprofit corporation.
“Idaho’s applicable statutes, in our view, do not authorize the District to simply fund a private nonprofit entity,” Deputy Attorney General Brett DeLange wrote in a letter dated Oct. 16 to both Bonner General and the public hospital district.
Elsaesser pushed back on notions that any money was spent inappropriately and said the hospital is complying with guidance it receives from legal counsel.
“We take seriously the advice of the attorney general, and we’re acting on it,” Elsaesser said. “We think the attorney general is there to assist situations like this and if they suggest that we should revise our agreement, then we’ve gone ahead and revised our agreement in a manner that we think will easily meet with their approval.”
Elsaesser said that such an agreement likely would give an ownership stake of some of Bonner General’s clinics to the hospital district, as was done to resolve a similar issue with two St. Luke’s Hospitals in McCall and Mountain Home three years ago.
But Rose and Smith said such an agreement wouldn’t avoid potential further legal action.
“We’ve been trying to avoid a lawsuit,” said Smith, who provided copies of letters sent to prosecutors in Bonner County that cite the state’s laws on racketeering that he believes are applicable to the case. “There’s a slew of civil causes of action available.”
Elsaesser called allegations of criminal conduct “ridiculous.”
“It’s just silly,” he said. “All of these people are public servants that are coming in at 7 a.m. to a board meeting to simply make sure there’s good governance of these hospitals.”
Local journalism is essential.
The journalists of The Spokesman-Review are a part of the community. They live here. They work here. They care. You can help keep local journalism strong right now with your contribution. Thank you.
Subscribe to the Coronavirus newsletter
Get the day’s latest Coronavirus news delivered to your inbox by subscribing to our newsletter.