A Spokane County jury on Wednesday convicted Joshua J. Mobley, 31, of beating a 10-month-old baby to death. Mobley was babysitting the baby in 2017 when the infant suffered more a dozen blows to the head that ultimately killed him.
Mobley, who had been allowed to remain out of custody after posting a $250,000 bond, was ordered to be detained in the Spokane County Jail following the verdict. Defense attorney Carl Oreskovich said his client faces up to life in prison after the jury found him guilty of second-degree murder and that the baby, Caiden Henry, was a particularly vulnerable victim.
“It was really about justice for baby Caiden,” Deputy Spokane County prosecutor Stefanie Collins said after the verdict. “It doesn’t bring Caiden back, but it holds his killer accountable and affords his mother the opportunity to at least start the process of healing.”
Defense attorney Carl Oreskovich, who argued in closing arguments on Tuesday that Caiden’s mother, Crystal Henry, may have caused the injuries that killed her infant son, asked Superior Court Judge Julie McKay to allow Mobley to remain out of custody pending sentencing. The judge denied the ruling and ordered transport deputies to take him into custody.
“Once he and his family get passed the shock of the verdict, we will decide what the next step will be,” Oreskovich said.
The jury deliberated about two hours on Wednesday after attorneys finished hours of closing arguments at the end of Tuesday in the two-week long trial. The case began when Caiden was discovered dead by his mother in the early morning hours of Feb. 27, 2017, after Caiden had spent hours in the care of Joshua Mobley.
As the attorneys waited, Collins paced back and forth and stared at the ground. Oreskovich stood in court with his arms crossed and his head tilted slighlty to the right. Because of the capacity crowd, Judge McKay moved the verdict to a larger courtroom.
When McKay read the verdict, Joshua Mobley looked straight ahead and showed no emotion as members of his family gasped, and his wife, Jennifer, began crying.
As the attorneys walked through the Mobley family, one woman yelled “You bitch, you bitch” at Collins, the prosecutor. Spokane Police detective Jeff Barrington, who was with Collins, looked at the woman who yelled and said, “Really?”
Jennifer Mobley, who previously worked with Crystal Henry and helped care for Caiden, had no comment when she was approached following the jury’s decision.
In addition to finding Joshua Mobley guilty of killing Caiden, the jury also found that Caiden was a particularly vulnerable victim. As a result of that enhancement, Judge McKay could sentence Mobley up to life in prison at the sentencing, which she scheduled for Aug. 9.
Oreskovich argued that his client should remain out of custody pending that sentencing.
“He has been released since shortly after his arrest” in February, 2017, he said. “He is home with his children with supervision. He has shown the ability to comply with the court’s orders. I ask you to continue the release conditions as they are.”
Collins told McKay that the “risk of flight is substantial” following the guilty verdict. “We ask you detain him pending sentencing.”
McKay agreed with Collins to keep Mobley in jail pending the August sentencing.
As part of those previous release conditions, Mobley was allowed to remain with his wife and even fathered a fourth child since he was charged with Caiden’s death. He was also allowed to be near family members who testified for the defense.
Several of Mobley’s family members testified that Joshua Mobley showed them Caiden on the night of Feb. 26, 2017, and he had none of the bruises shown in autopsy photos. Medical testimony indicated that Caiden slowly died after suffering several blows to the head and trauma to the abdomen that caused internal bleeding.
As a result of the family testimony, Oreskovich argued in his closing arguments that perhaps Caiden’s mother, Crystal Henry, caused the 12 to 20 blows that caused Caiden’s death.
“We don’t have to prove to you that Crystal Henry did it. She was in a fog. She was medicated,” Oreskovich said on Tuesday. “Maybe Crystal Henry snapped. I ask you to find Joshua Mobley not guilty.”
Through her attorney, Dennis Cronin, Crystal Henry said she wanted to hold back most of her remarks about the case until she gets a chance to speak at sentencing.
“She’d like to recognize and thank the efforts of the prosecution team for attaining justice for baby Caiden,” Cronin said.
Local journalism is essential.
Give directly to The Spokesman-Review's Northwest Passages community forums series -- which helps to offset the costs of several reporter and editor positions at the newspaper -- by using the easy options below. Gifts processed in this system are not tax deductible, but are predominately used to help meet the local financial requirements needed to receive national matching-grant funds.
Subscribe to the Coronavirus newsletter
Get the day’s latest Coronavirus news delivered to your inbox by subscribing to our newsletter.