Arrow-right Camera

The Spokesman-Review Newspaper The Spokesman-Review

Wednesday, January 29, 2020  Spokane, Washington  Est. May 19, 1883
Cloudy 39° Cloudy
A&E >  Pop culture

Han and Greedo shooting scene changed again (and probably not the way you wanted)

This photo provided by Lucasfilm shows Peter Mayhew as Chewbacca and Harrison Ford as Han Solo in "Star Wars: The Force Awakens," directed by J.J. Abrams. (AP)
This photo provided by Lucasfilm shows Peter Mayhew as Chewbacca and Harrison Ford as Han Solo in "Star Wars: The Force Awakens," directed by J.J. Abrams. (AP)
By Alex Horton The Washington Post

There is no dispute about how Greedo, the mediocre gunslinger in “A New Hope,” met his fate: Han Solo shot him in a darkened cantina before Greedo could pull the trigger.

That was in 1977 before “Star Wars” creator George Lucas tweaked that sequence of events so many times that it has since become a sci-fi Zapruder film scrutinized by fans who have become experts in galactic rules of engagement.

Most of the changes have revolved around the milliseconds between the characters firing their blasters.

But in what is at least the fifth version of the scene that circulated Tuesday after the launch of Disney Plus, Greedo belts out a curious phrase before the carnage begins: “Maclunkey.”


The change touched off a firestorm of discussion on social media speculating about what actually led to this latest controversy.

Did “maclunkey” amount to a war cry or a plea for Han not to shoot?

Fan linguists (yeah, it’s a thing) speculated it was “ma klounkee,” or in Huttese, “This will be the end of you.”

Back up. What is going on?

The cantina shooting is perhaps the most amended 10 seconds in cinema history.

In the original theatrical release, Han Solo - the roguish, scruffy-looking smuggler - is set to provide transport for Luke Skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi off the desert planet Tatooine.

But he runs into a complication. He owes the universe-wide kingpin Jabba the Hutt a lot of money, and Greedo, the spiky-head Rodian bounty hunter, is looking to collect. Greedo shoves Han into a booth at gunpoint. He tells Han he looked forward to this encounter.

Meanwhile, Han unholsters a blaster under the table. “Yeah, I’ll bet you have,” Han says before he shoots Greedo point blank.

The scene said something important about Han.

He is unafraid to kill if he his cornered, and the shooting was either coldblooded or a justifiable defense depending on your perspective. It added a complexity to a character who fluidly moves from selfishness to great risks for his rebel friends.

But then the first controversial change.

In 1997, for the 20th anniversary rerelease of the film in theaters and VHS, Lucas introduced a number of alterations, including the addition of digital aliens.

But the most assailed change by far occurred in the Han and Greedo scene. In this new version, Greedo pulls the trigger first in a wild shot, missing Han by half a parsec. Han responds with a clunky CGI dodge, then fires at Greedo.

The change essentially recasts Han’s response from a pre-emptive killing to a victim responding to a violent bounty hunter’s wild misfire.

It did not go over well. “Han shot first” became an instant rallying cry on pre-social media messages boards, and T-shirts were created to send fans back into a simpler time.

It changes again and again (and again).

Subsequent releases have shaved off the moment before the laser fire exchange, though never appeasing most of the fan base upset over the revisionist moment.

In 2004, for the DVD release of the original trilogy, Han still dodges, but he is much quicker on the draw, pulling the trigger right after Greedo fires.

Then, in 2011, Lucas and company took a scalpel to the celluloid for the Blu-ray release, removing a few more slivers in between the exchange.

You can only tell Greedo fires first if you slow down the playback. Otherwise, it appears Han is lucky Greedo is a bad shot.

And now?

The new addition of Greedo’s “maclunkey” was years in the making. Lucas himself oversaw the change before he sold his franchise to Disney in 2012, Vanity Fair reported.

That change could have been prepared for a 3D release that never occurred and was shelved until now, io9 speculated. Lucasfilm did not return a request for comment.

Subscribe to the Spokane7 email newsletter

Get the day’s top entertainment headlines delivered to your inbox every morning.

You have been successfully subscribed!
There was a problem subscribing you to the newsletter. Double check your email and try again, or email