Arrow-right Camera
Subscribe now

This column reflects the opinion of the writer. Learn about the differences between a news story and an opinion column.

Spin Control: Despite Culp’s claim, ‘Get a rope’ is no metaphor for accountability

Republican Loren Culp is cheered on by hundreds of supporters during a rally on Oct. 2, 2020, in Spokane Valley during Culp’s unsuccessful run for governor. He is now running for Congress in central Washington, hoping to unseat Republican Don Newhouse.  (COLIN MULVANY/The Spokesman-Review)

When a man allegedly attacked a Seattle nurse in early March, knocking her down the stairs of a light-rail station for no apparent reason, breaking her ribs and clavicle, many people were shocked.

When it was revealed the 40-year-old homeless man has an extensive criminal record, as well as a history of not showing up to court, and may have stabbed another woman multiple times the previous day, many were outraged.

The man, who was arrested shortly after the attack at the station, was arraigned on multiple assault charges and held on a $650,000 bond. But that didn’t stop the discussion of what steps should have been taken to prevent a person with such a long criminal history from being out in public where he could commit more.

Loren Culp, the former Republican gubernatorial candidate now seeking to unseat U.S. Rep. Dan Newhouse in Central Washington’s 4th Congressional District, offered a solution that set off a back-and-forth between him and the Seattle Times.

“Get a rope,” he tweeted about 10 days after the arrest, “not only for the low life scumbag who did this but for the worthless judges and prosecutors who continually let this happen by turning violent criminals back out only to make new victims. No rope, firing squad and I’ll volunteer for it.”

This prompted Times columnist Danny Westneat to wonder about the silence from others in the state Republican Party about Culp calling for a lynching, not only of the suspect in the assaults but judges and prosecutors.

While the state GOP remained mostly mum, Culp later posted a long rebuttal, of sorts, on a notice of an upcoming campaign meet and greet in Grant County. He argued the phrase “Get a rope” was merely a metaphor that doesn’t mean vigilante justice – “which was clear to anyone with an IQ above room temperature,” he contended – “and means accountability (due process and jail time) for the violent offenders, the prosecutors who enable them and the judges who set them free.”

Assuming that’s a serious rejoinder and not an attempt to get a second round of accolades from supporters by topping the post with “Thank God for the fake news Seattle Times,” there are three problems with his explanation.

First, it’s not strictly a metaphor, as a simple declarative sentence where there’s no comparison of two seemingly different objects. If he intended it as a figure of speech, it is perhaps more correctly a hyperbole expressed as an exclamation. But this is politics, not seventh grade English.

Second, it is much more likely to be understood by anyone reading the tweet in the historic context of a call for vigilante justice as in an Old West hanging, or the racial injustice of a Jim Crow lynching.

Angry white residents trying to block racial integration of their schools by Black children often carried the phrase on signs, sometimes along with the drawing of a noose.

Movies are replete with the phrase, going back almost to the time when sound started accompanying images on the screen. A quick internet check of movie quotes shows it appears in such Westerns as “Tombstone,” “The Life and Times of Judge Roy Bean,” “The Westerner,” “The Lawman,” “Sons of Katie Elder,” and “The Streets of Laredo,” as well non-Westerns such as a version of “Robin Hood” and “Stalag 17.”

Paul Stekler, a documentarian and professor of public affairs and radio-television-film at the University of Texas, said there’s only one clear meaning of the phrase.

“You’re essentially making a comment that is about a hanging,” said Stekler, who wrote about the phrase and its context after a pair of Texas politicians, including Gov. Greg Abbott, used it then tried to pass it off as a mere joke related to an old commercial.

“Get a rope” was a tag line for a 1980s Pace salsa commercial in which the cook on a cattle drive, naturally named Cookie, commits the “crime” of using salsa from New York City when they run out of salsa from San Antonio. But even in that context, it’s about a hanging, and politicians use it deliberately knowing that, he said.

“You rev up the base by saying the most outrageous stuff you can,” Stekler said.

The third thing that undercuts Culp’s suggestion that he was just calling for accountability, not an execution, is the end of his original tweet. Firing squads aren’t a metaphor for anything, and they definitely mean more than “due process and jail time” when applied to judges and prosecutors, as the former police chief might be expected to know.

Culp finds himself in a hotly contested primary for the congressional seat, one of five Republicans trying to unseat the incumbent. Based on the most recent Federal Election Commission reports filed at the end of last year, he’s running third in fundraising, behind Newhouse and newcomer Jerrod Sessler.

He’s competing with Sessler for the pro-Trump vote among Republicans who still may be torqued at Newhouse for voting to certify Joe Biden as the new president on Jan. 6, 2021, and a week later voting to impeach the former president. Even if the funding disparity continues, Culp has one thing that might be more valuable: Trump’s endorsement. His “get a rope” comment is unlikely to hurt him with the segment of the former president’s voters who applauded when Trump called on a crowd to “knock the crap” out of hecklers.

The real question is, will it hurt him with other Republicans whose belief in law and order has evolved beyond a rope and a tree limb?

More from this author