‘You guys would probably be crying really hard’

The sleepy child, speaking with difficulty, told Capt. Dan Mattos about Duncan’s molesting of her and her brother, and said he also forced them to do things he videotaped. She said she saw the movie of Duncan torturing Dylan at an old cabin near their remote campsite. “If you guys probably got hold of it, you guys would probably be crying really hard – it was just a terrible movie,” the youngster told the police officer.

While the videotaped interview played in the courtroom, jurors watched intently, some cupping their hands over their mouths. Duncan looked down, and for much of it, closed his eyes and rested his chin on his clasped hands, appearing to be praying.