Thoma should be in prison

The debate over whether or not alcoholism qualifies as a disability deserving of recognition under the Americans with Disabilities Act is a red herring designed to distract from the only reason that former Sgt. Brad Thoma was fired from the police force: He broke the law. Alcohol is a contributing factor, but it is not an excuse, nor does it warrant sympathy for Thoma’s actions.

As an analogy, replace the use of prescription drugs for alcohol. There is no cause of action against someone for taking his own legally prescribed pain medication; however, should that person be caught selling his prescription drugs, he has then committed a crime. His personal drug use – even if it is addiction – is not the issue, his criminal activity is.

Whether or not alcoholism can be classified as a disability is a moot point. Thoma was not fired from the police force for being an alcoholic; he was fired for criminal behavior. He has accepted zero responsibility; indeed, he has given every indication that he is an unrepentant, habitual drunken driver and will repeat offend.

My daughter was killed on Sept. 16, 2011, by a repeat-offending drunken driver.

Thoma belongs in prison.

Susan Schaar

Spokane