Cindy: My Queendom For A Novel

On her Facebook wall, Cindy posts: ” Sam is having a hard time choosing a book to read for Honors English. Rebecca was a non-starter. So was The Chosen. Now we’re on to The Yearling and Robinson Crusoe. This book talk prompted Derek’s review of the following: Catcher in the Rye: “Hated that book. That kid was so depressing.” All Quiet on the Western Front: “Hated the ending. Paul dies? I mean give me a freaking break.”
Not. Helpful.

Question: Which book would you recommend for Sam? And why?