Conspicuous Tip Cups Trigger Debate Workers Welcome Extra Income, But Others Call It Begging

Standing smack on top of the cash register between Seman Fedil and his customers is a battered plastic foam cup he personalized with his name and a hopeful hint: “Tips.”

While a common sight in trendy coffee shops nationwide, the tip cup seems somewhat out of place in this downtown Philadelphia Dunkin’ Donuts, part of an age-old chain whose uniformed workers have been dishing out doughnuts and java to take-out customers for 50 years.

“I was surprised to see the tip cups,” said Toni Ogle, reluctantly tossing a quarter into an empty cup before leaving with her coffee. “What do they do to get a tip? They’re waiting on you. They’re getting paid for it.”

With Pavlovian reflex, customers are dumping money into tip containers left and right these days, leaving coffee shops, ice cream parlors and greasy sandwich joints to cash in on a growing trend that preys on pity.

It’s no different in Spokane and Coeur d’Alene’s coffee and sandwich shops. Workers can earn anywhere from 50 cents to $10 to $15 per day from tip cups.

“We really don’t ask for it,” said Becki Diehl, a worker at Great Harvest Bread Co. in downtown Spokane. People throwing change in the jar seem to want to get rid of it, Diehl said.

Anne McKendrick, manager of Java on Sherman in Coeur d’Alene, said her employees earn a few extra dollars daily from the tip jar.

“If you deserve the tip, you get it, if you don’t, you don’t,” she said.

But not everyone thinks tip cups are such a great trend.

“I think it’s rude,” said Tom Wall, owner of the Baskin Robbins ice cream store on Country Homes Boulevard in Spokane. “I think a tip should be earned and not requested. If I see a cup and it says that on it, I never put anything in it.”

Christopher Muller, an assistant professor in Cornell University’s School of Hotel Administration, agrees.

“It doesn’t take a genius to figure out that if you put a cup out someone will put a tip in it. It’s begging,” said Muller.

“Why do we tip people for doing their job well?” he asked. “Do you leave $10 in an envelope for the garbage guys at Christmas? Does it mean that they’ll toss the garbage on the lawn if you don’t?”

Tip cups seem to be popping up in minimum-wage retail establishments that seldom solicited gratuities until recently.

“I have noticed that as a new phenomenon in the last five years - I saw it in the West Coast and here in the Rocky Mountain region coffee houses and other kinds of delis, small outlets that don’t have table service, have these tipping jars,” said Kim Long, who documents annual trends in The American Forecaster Almanac, published in Denver.

“If this is spreading, it ought to spread outside of coffee shops, and therefore at some movie theater somewhere in the U.S., someone’s going to put a tip jar on the counter next to the popcorn machine,” Long said.

Long speculates that the tip cup phenomenon is rooted in the growth of gourmet coffee shops, which invite tips by showering customers with smiles and specializing in hard-to-make coffee concoctions.

Seattle-based Starbucks is at the forefront of the coffee shop phenomenon, boasting more than 960 stores nationwide and aiming for 2,000 worldwide by the end of the millennium, said spokeswoman Jeanne McKay.

Unlike many food and beverage retailers, Starbucks pays part- and full-time workers starting wages of $6 to $7 an hour and offers generous benefits and stock packages.

Even so, tip cups abound. The company allows workers to display 4-by-4-inch, unmarked Plexiglas cups by its registers.

“We try to be subtle,” McKay said. “We don’t want to shove it down customers’ throats and make them feel like they have to tip.”

At Dunkin’ Donuts, individual store owners decide whether employees can display tip cups as a way of boosting morale, said Jennifer Rosenberg, spokeswoman for the Randolph, Mass., company.

The mere presence of the tip cup, however unobtrusive, can be psychologically potent.

“It’s an intimidation strategy. You put a cup out and people feel like they have to put money in it, and they don’t know why,” said Cornell’s Muller.

Take Marie Raggio. Moments after being handed change for a cup of hazelnut-flavored coffee, Raggio flipped her right wrist over the Starbucks tip cup, opened her hand and let loose a fistful of coins.

“I should have a reason for giving my money away - especially as an accountant for a law firm,” Raggio said, smiling as she searched for an explanation. “Maybe it’s because I see the cup there.”

Jamie Rubin, 20, knows the benefits of a well-placed tip cup. As a part-time worker at Ashley’s Ice Cream in New Haven, Conn., the college student has taken home as much as $30 in tips on a good night.

“It’s real important, because we only get paid $5 an hour,” said Rubin, who attends Southern Connecticut University. “It really makes a difference.”

, DataTimes ILLUSTRATION: Color Photo