Some worry if rise in egg donations just for cash
CHICAGO – Human egg donation was a rarity not so long ago. But heightened demand for eggs – and rising compensation for donors – are prompting more young women to consider it.
Jennifer Dziura, a 28-year-old New Yorker, is one of them.
She received $8,000 to donate her eggs in the fall of 2005 and hopes she’ll be chosen again before the private egg broker she’s registered with considers her too old. She realizes prospective parents who view her profile might think it a minus that her father is adopted, allowing for little medical history from his side. She also figures some are looking for a blonde, instead of a brunette.
“But, hey, I have perfect SAT scores,” Dziura, an aspiring comedian and model, says with a slight chuckle.
As more older moms look for help getting pregnant, younger women have become increasingly willing to part with their eggs. Some do it to help relatives and friends, or from a sense of altruism, but others openly acknowledge money is a big factor in their decision, prompting critics to worry that they’re helping drive an unregulated market for human tissue.
A decade ago, Dr. Joel Brasch, a fertility specialist in the Chicago area, had to work hard to recruit five or 10 young women for his own practice’s donor pool – but not anymore.
The money is seen as compensation for time and trouble. Among other things, donors learn to inject themselves with hormones and, eventually, have a needle inserted through their vaginal wall so eggs can be harvested.
The American Society of Reproductive Medicine has set a compensation guideline of $5,000, with a limit of $10,000 for special cases – if, for instance, a recipient wants eggs of rare ancestry.
The president of the Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology, an affiliate of ASRM, argues that if women were just motivated by money, they wouldn’t get past the psychological screening. And, he says, researchers who’ve surveyed donors have found another strong motive.
“They’re very altruistic and very willing to help a couple who’s trying to conceive,” says Dr. David Grainger, who’s also a reproductive endocrinologist at University of Kansas medical school in Wichita.
Still, some egg brokers – particularly those in the East and West – are ignoring suggestions for a cap on compensation, and paying women more.
“It does feel a little more like the Wild West than it ought to,” says Dr. Jeffrey Kahn, director of the University of Minnesota Center for Bioethics. “We worry that we offer people so much money that they are blind to the risk and their motivation is strictly the money.”
That’s the very reason, he notes, that it is illegal to sell an organ, such as a kidney, for donation. “So I’m not comfortable saying we should start that with human eggs,” he says.