Complete Coverage

News >  Idaho

Duncan lawyers seek sentence delay

BOISE – Attorneys for convicted murderer Joseph Edward Duncan III are asking a federal judge to postpone his sentencing hearing on 10 federal charges until September, and to prevent the only surviving victim from testifying about the effect the deaths of her mother, older brother and family friend had on her. The flurry of defense motions, filed in U.S. District Court on Tuesday and Wednesday, also include a request to take the death penalty off the table for one of the charges against Duncan.
News >  Idaho

Duncan evidence won’t be suppressed

BOISE – A federal judge has rejected defense attorneys' motions to suppress evidence seized from the vehicle Joseph Duncan was driving when he was found with young Shasta Groene, the only survivor of Duncan's bloody attack on her family.
News >  Idaho

Shasta told police of Duncan’s claims

BOISE – Shasta Groene told authorities that Joseph Duncan, during the weeks he held her captive at a remote Montana campsite, described killing at least three other children – a tip that prompted authorities to investigate Duncan as a possible serial killer. In federal court hearings Tuesday and Wednesday, documents submitted into evidence and testimony from law enforcement witnesses showed that the 8-year-old girl, just hours after her rescue from Duncan on July 2, 2005, told police about Duncan's possible prior crimes.
News >  Idaho

Shooting details revealed at Duncan hearing

BOISE – The night she was rescued from killer Joseph Duncan, young Shasta Groene gave such a vivid description of Duncan's killing of her brother, Dylan, that it left little doubt that 9-year-old Dylan was dead. Nevertheless, authorities anxiously hunted for Dylan out of fear he might still be alive. Kootenai County Sheriff's Detective Sgt. Brad Maskell said Duncan earlier had left both children chained to a tree in the forest and "our concern was that that situation still existed."
News >  Idaho

Shasta’s advocate fights delay

BOISE – The court-appointed advocate for Shasta Groene said in court papers Friday that even if the child doesn't have to testify against Joseph Duncan, it's in her best interest to have all the proceedings in his case wrapped up as soon as possible. John Sahlin, guardian ad litem for Shasta, argued that all proceedings in the case should be finished "on or before June 1, 2008, so that SG may have a summer to enjoy and prepare for her transition to public middle school, a major life transition for her."
News >  Idaho

Shasta won’t need to testify

BOISE – Shasta Groene won't have to testify in federal court against killer Joseph Duncan under an agreement reached by both sides in the case. "The parties will stipulate that S.G. will not be called as a witness at the capital sentencing hearing," federal prosecutors wrote in a motion filed with the court this week. "Her testimony will be presented by statements she made to law enforcement officers in July 2005."
News >  Idaho

Duncan admits to all 10 counts

BOISE – A chilling tale of child molestation and murder emerged in a Boise courtroom Monday, as Joseph Duncan pleaded guilty to all counts in a federal indictment for kidnapping and molesting two North Idaho children in 2005 and killing one. The remaining question is whether Duncan will be put to death for his crimes or spend the rest of his life in prison. A federal jury will be convened late next month to decide that.
News >  Spokane

Guilty plea without deal is unusual, attorneys say

Joseph Duncan's decision to plead guilty to capital crimes without an agreement to avoid a death sentence is unusual but not unprecedented, said attorneys familiar with death penalty cases. "It is more common for people to plead guilty after death is taken off the table," said Jacqueline McMurtrie, a professor at the University of Washington Law School.
News >  Idaho

Duncan may plead guilty

BOISE – Joseph Duncan, who has been charged with kidnapping two North Idaho children in 2005 and killing one of them, is scheduled to enter a guilty plea Monday in federal court. A court document filed late Friday does not detail exactly which charges Duncan will plead to. But the penalty phase of his case now is due to begin Jan. 28, the document noted.
News >  Idaho

Duncan puts death penalty on trial

BOISE – As Joseph Duncan awaits a federal trial that could bring a death sentence, the notorious North Idaho murderer's case is becoming the focus of arguments about whether the federal death penalty is even constitutional. Duncan's attorneys have filed legal arguments saying the federal death penalty is imposed so rarely – it's resulted in only three executions in the past 40 years – that it's clearly arbitrary and unfair. Most crimes just as horrendous as those that draw the death penalty result in lesser sentences, for no apparent reason, the lawyers argue.
News >  Idaho

Duncan lawyers challenge jury rules

BOISE – Attorneys for convicted murderer Joseph Duncan have filed papers in court seeking to have his federal indictment for kidnapping, killing and child molesting thrown out because they contend Idaho's grand juror selection rules are unconstitutional. A federal grand jury indicted Duncan on 10 counts last January. His federal trial is scheduled to start in January.
News >  Idaho

Duncan’s January trial date unchanged

BOISE – Joseph Duncan's attorneys have plenty of time to prepare for a January trial, U.S. District Judge Edward Lodge declared Friday, and he refused to let Duncan's former lead attorney walk away from the case. The judge rejected bids from the defense to delay for a year the trial of the man accused of one of North Idaho's most notorious crimes – a multiple murder, kidnapping and child-molesting case that left four victims dead in 2005.
News >  Idaho

Clarke to head Duncan team

The attorney who defended Unabomber Ted Kaczynski and child-killer Susan Smith will head Joseph Duncan's federal defense team. Judy Clarke, formerly federal defender for Eastern Washington and Idaho, is leading the team of attorneys representing the suspected serial killer.
News >  Idaho

Computer experts to testify at Duncan trial

Three computer forensic experts will testify at killer Joseph Duncan's federal trial about the pictures, videos and journal entries found on his computer equipment, federal prosecutors said in a court filing Tuesday. Duncan is facing the death penalty if convicted in his January 2008 trial for the murder of 9-year-old Dylan Groene and other crimes against the boy and his sister, Shasta.
News >  Idaho

Duncan misses deadline for wrongful death suit

BOISE – Convicted murderer and sex offender Joseph Duncan failed to reply in time to a wrongful death lawsuit filed by the father of the children Duncan is accused of killing or kidnapping, according to a finding entered into federal court Friday. Duncan was found in default of the lawsuit filed by Steven Groene. The finding, entered by a clerk in U.S. District Court here at Groene's request, allows Groene to ask Judge B. Lynn Winmill to rule in his favor in the civil suit without hearing from Duncan.
News >  Idaho

Judge splits Duncan ruling

Federal prosecutors can't have a log of Joseph Duncan's prison visitors, but U.S. District Judge Edward Lodge is allowing prosecutors to see some of the convicted killer's mail. Defense attorneys filed a sealed motion for a protective order to keep prosecutors from obtaining the information, which they argued would reveal defense strategy in the federal death penalty case.
News >  Idaho

Amid storm, Douglas confident

Kootenai County Prosecutor Bill Douglas wants to be remembered as a good boss and a "fair, ethical prosecutor who was a voice for crime victims and who held criminals accountable." He hopes his 18-year career as elected prosecutor won't be overshadowed by recent controversies, including the release of sexually charged e-mails he exchanged at work with former employee Marina Kalani.
News >  Idaho

Gag order issued in Duncan trial

U.S. District Judge Edward J. Lodge has issued a gag order to quell pretrial publicity in the federal case against convicted killer Joseph Duncan. Attorneys, witnesses and prospective witnesses in the death penalty case are barred from talking about the case, other than quoting from what's already in the public record, according to an order Lodge issued Friday.