| Year | Name | School | Sport | Grade | Pos. | Award |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1991 | Shawn Saling | Central Valley | Boys Basketball | 12 | First Team | |
| 1991 | Josh Schroeder | Ferris | Boys Basketball | 12 | First Team | |
| 1991 | Jason Powers | Gonzaga Prep | Boys Basketball | 11 | First Team | |
| 1991 | Deven Frigaard | North Central | Boys Basketball | 12 | First Team | |
| 1991 | Mike Cady | Shadle Park | Boys Basketball | 12 | First Team | |
| 1991 | Laura Fralich | Central Valley | Girls Basketball | 11 | First Team | |
| 1991 | Courtney Hepton | Central Valley | Girls Basketball | 12 | First Team | |
| 1991 | Kirsti Olson | Lewis and Clark | Girls Basketball | 11 | First Team | |
| 1991 | Colleen Flanigan | Mead | Girls Basketball | 12 | First Team | |
| 1991 | Jeanna Hall | Mead | Girls Basketball | 12 | First Team | |
| 1991 | Beth Wright | Shadle Park | Girls Basketball | 12 | First Team | |
| 1991 | Sean Cavanaugh | Gonzaga Prep | Football | 12 | Offensive Line | First Team Offense |
| 1991 | Justin Strand | Gonzaga Prep | Football | 11 | Running Back | First Team Offense |
| 1991 | Ben Cater | Lewis and Clark | Football | 11 | Kicker | First Team Offense |
| 1991 | Jason Baldwin | Mead | Football | 11 | Running Back | First Team Offense |
| 1991 | Jeff Barnard | Mead | Football | 12 | Offensive Line | First Team Offense |
| 1991 | Jason Welch | Mead | Football | 12 | Quarterback | First Team Offense |
| 1991 | Garret Carlson | North Central | Football | 12 | Wide Receiver | First Team Offense |
| 1991 | Mike Cady | Shadle Park | Football | 12 | Tight End | First Team Offense |
| 1991 | Brandon Donahue | Shadle Park | Football | 12 | Offensive Line | First Team Offense |
| 1991 | Bret Nine | Shadle Park | Football | 12 | Running Back | First Team Offense |
| 1991 | Bret Nine | Shadle Park | Football | 12 | Running Back | First Team Offense |
| 1991 | Joe Veale | Shadle Park | Football | 12 | Offensive Line | First Team Offense |
| 1991 | Chad Berry | University | Football | 12 | Wide Receiver | First Team Offense |
| 1991 | Tom Merritt | University | Football | 12 | Offensive Line | First Team Offense |
| 1991 | Brett Bellinger | Lewis and Clark | Football | 11 | Punter | First Team Defense |
| 1991 | Jeff Raymond | Lewis and Clark | Football | 12 | Linebacker | First Team Defense |
| 1991 | Jeff Aden | Mead | Football | 12 | Linebacker | First Team Defense |
| 1991 | Jon Kincaid | Mead | Football | 12 | Defensive Back | First Team Defense |
| 1991 | Rich Phillips | Mead | Football | 11 | Defensive Line | First Team Defense |
| 1991 | Daren Phillipy | Mead | Football | 12 | Linebacker | First Team Defense |
| 1991 | Cory Solomon | Mead | Football | 11 | Defensive Line | First Team Defense |
| 1991 | Keith Wallingford | North Central | Football | 12 | Linebacker | First Team Defense |
| 1991 | Hans Giesa | Shadle Park | Football | 12 | Defensive Back | First Team Defense |
| 1991 | Randy Kilmer | Shadle Park | Football | 12 | Defensive Line | First Team Defense |
| 1991 | Randy Kilmer | Shadle Park | Football | 12 | Defensive Line | First Team Defense |
| 1991 | James Smith | Shadle Park | Football | 12 | Defensive Line | First Team Defense |
| 1991 | Adam Daniel | University | Football | 12 | Defensive Back | First Team Defense |
| 1991 | Monte LaBrosse | University | Football | 12 | Defensive Line | First Team Defense |
| 1991 | Jacob Grant | Ferris | Boys Basketball | 12 | Second Team | |
| 1991 | Jesse Etter | North Central | Boys Basketball | 12 | Second Team | |
| 1991 | Aaron Shepherd | North Central | Boys Basketball | 11 | Second Team | |
| 1991 | Hans Giesa | Shadle Park | Boys Basketball | 12 | Second Team | |
| 1991 | Kurt Heimbigner | University | Boys Basketball | 11 | Second Team | |
| 1991 | Luc Johnson | University | Boys Basketball | 12 | Second Team | |
| 1991 | Kelli Patterson | Central Valley | Girls Basketball | 12 | Second Team | |
| 1991 | Nicole Zelinski | Mead | Girls Basketball | 12 | Second Team | |
| 1991 | Michelle Greenwood | North Central | Girls Basketball | 11 | Second Team | |
| 1991 | Jennifer Tissue | Shadle Park | Girls Basketball | 11 | Second Team | |
| 1991 | Julie Anderegg | University | Girls Basketball | 12 | Second Team |