Arrow-right Camera
The Spokesman-Review Newspaper
Spokane, Washington  Est. May 19, 1883

‘Garden of Beasts’ tells tale of hit man in Nazi Germany

John Orr San Jose Mercury News

Jeffery Deaver has made a nice living writing about sociopaths in novels such as “The Bone Collector” and “The Coffin Dancer,” so it makes sense for him to take on Nazi Germany — which he does in “Garden of Beasts.”

It’s an excellent mystery thriller, filled with Deaver’s usual deep research and superior writing, but one that may be a bit too subtle for some of his fans.

Those who come to Deaver for nightmare-inducing thrills will find only hints of that scariness in “Garden of Beasts,” despite the horrors of his source material.

There are deaths, constant danger and clever twists of plot, but not the razor’s edge of creepiness that puts adrenaline in the blood of readers, as in Deaver’s earlier books.

Some may have to work a little harder to get into this book, but “Garden of Beasts” will reward the effort.

It’s a fascinating look at Nazi Germany, told largely from what may be a unique perspective: that of an American “button man,” Paul Schumann, who’s been hired to hit Reinhard Ernst, Hitler’s “brains behind rearmament.”

The powerful men who want Schumann for the job tell him it’s because he is fluent in German and they know he’s smart: “What we’ve heard about you is that you check everything two, three times before the job. You make sure your guns’re in perfect shape, you read up about your victims … you know when they’ll be alone, when they make phone calls, where they eat.”

That little speech ends up being somewhat ironic later in the book, when Deaver’s signature twists and turns heat up, and a possible double- or triple-crosser apparently forgets Schumann’s intelligence and ability.

What’s in it for Schumann?

A “get-out-of-jail-free card,” a large wad of cash and having his record completely expunged. And two other benefits: He’d been in the Army in World War I and doesn’t like this talk of Hitler starting another war. And he thinks that Ernst’s real importance to him is that he will be the last man that he would ever kill.

We like Schumann. He is an honorable killer who targets only bad men, a process he calls “correcting God’s mistakes.”

Incognito on the ocean crossing, he works out with the young boxers on the Olympic team and makes friends with Jesse Owens.

But a body hits the cobblestones almost as soon as Schumann gets to Germany. He goes to an alley where he is to meet his contact and is accosted by a man with a gun — who is in turn shot by someone else. The shooter identifies himself as Schumann’s contact and tells him “you’ve been in town for less than a day, and already we’ve managed to kill a Stormtrooper.”

They take the body’s identification papers and depart. Before long police Inspector Willi Kohl is on scene. And he’s good.

He learns that the tall man seen near where the body was found had whistled for a taxi: “One whistled for dogs and horses. But to summon a taxi this way would demean the driver. … Did this suggest that the suspect was a foreigner? Or merely rude? He jotted the observation into his notebook.”

Soon it is a race between Schumann and Kohl. Schumann wants to ice Ernst and get out of town; Kohl wants to find the killer of the mysterious body.

Schumann’s task is complicated by having to survive in Hitler’s Germany. He is at first confused by the yellow paint splashed on some of the homes in the otherwise immaculate city of Berlin (marking the residences of Jews). Then he gets in a tussle with some Hitler Youths. Then he falls in love with a starving refugee.

Kohl has to contend with the new levels of bureaucracy and paranoia among government agencies in Berlin. A gifted detective and someone we come to like and admire, Kohl must deal with Nazi fanatics and members of other police agencies more interested in politics than in finding out who killed the man in the alley.

And Deaver lets us get to know Ernst, the man intended for Schumann’s gun sights. We meet his wife and his children; his chief competitor for favor, Hermann Goring; and his boss, Adolf Hitler.

It’s all part of Deaver’s mastery. He gives his readers at least something to like about each of the three major players in this story — Schumann, Kohl and Ernst — before making it clear where the real evil is hiding.