Pat Hoover and Susan Cundiff: Hanford watchdog needed to ensure accountability
Sat., Nov. 4, 2017
Where did you grow up? The answer to that question has been the most significant information in my (Patricia Hoover’s) medical history.
I spent my first 18 years downriver and downwind from the Hanford Nuclear Reservation. In the mid-1940s, when Hanford’s eight nuclear reactors went on line, my family, neighbors and those around us found with growing alarm and confusion that our formerly healthy lives were deteriorating. My community was struck with high rates of thyroid cancers, miscarriages, birth defects and many other anomalous medical conditions.
It took more than 40 years to verify our suspicion that the federal government had contaminated the air, water and food chain throughout the Northwest. In 1986, thousands of activists were finally granted a Freedom of Information Act request. Despite repeated government denial, 19,000 pages of operating documents confirmed that hundreds of thousands of curies of radiation were released from Hanford over years of operation.
The revelation finally explained numerous medical events that took place early in my life. It answered why men in lab coats came to my junior high health class in Hermiston, Oregon, to palpate the throat of every student as if it were part of the curriculum. I understood why my thyroid gland had quit functioning at age 11 and developed a tumor the size of a grapefruit 18 years later. I no longer considered my mysteriously fractured ankle and my classmates’ numerous broken bones to be normal childhood mishaps.
If you lived anywhere near one of America’s eight nuclear facilities – Richland, Washington; Los Alamos, New Mexico; Oak Ridge, Tennessee; Savannah River, South Carolina; Paducah, Kentucky; Denver; Idaho Falls, Idaho; or Amarillo, Texas – you may well have had similar experiences.
One of the few agencies that monitor and hold these nuclear sites accountable for rule-abiding operations is under attack internally. In a recently exposed letter, Sean Sullivan, the chairman of the Defense Nuclear Facilities Safety Board, urges the Trump administration to disband the board or drastically slash its budget.
This independent board has acted as an important watchdog over the nuclear weapons complex since Congress chartered it in 1988, and it is a transparent source of public information. It provides weekly reports, including contractors’ mistakes that may jeopardize the safety of 40,000 workers and nearby communities, and functions as an essential check and balance between the government and the nuclear industry. Sullivan’s action, undertaken without the knowledge of the four other board members, reflects the dangerous pattern of secrecy by which our nuclear weapons facilities have always operated.
Sullivan has himself stated that the board played a helpful role in protecting public health in its early years. He is, however, mistaken in calling the DNFSB an irrelevant “relic of the Cold War.” We live under a president who wants to see drastic growth in our nuclear stockpile. On top of his regular issuance of bombastic threats, the president has unilateral discretion over the arsenal’s use.
We are at the most critical moment in nuclear history since the Cuban missile crisis, and now is prime time to strengthen, rather than abolish, agencies like the DNFSB.
My downwinder medical history, and those of thousands of other Americans who grew up near nuclear plants, is evidence of the debilitating health effects of radiation. My experiences speak clearly to the absolute need to keep the DNFSB engaged in its significant role, regulating safe operations at all eight U.S. nuclear weapons facilities.
In recognition of this necessity, we encourage you to call your senators and your representatives. Urge them to speak up in Congress and oppose disbanding the Defense Nuclear Facilities Safety Board. This independent nuclear watchdog must continue its vital work.
Patricia Hoover, of Eugene, Oregon, is a Hanford Downwinder and member of Women’s Action for New Directions (WAND). Susan Cundiff, of Eugene, serves on the national board of WAND and leads the Oregon chapter.
Local journalism is essential.
Give directly to The Spokesman-Review's Northwest Passages community forums series -- which helps to offset the costs of several reporter and editor positions at the newspaper -- by using the easy options below. Gifts processed in this system are not tax deductible, but are predominately used to help meet the local financial requirements needed to receive national matching-grant funds.
Subscribe now to get breaking news alerts in your email inbox
Get breaking news delivered to your inbox as it happens.