Would you pay extra to talk to a human when travel plans go wrong?
The problem with artificial intelligence is simple: when travelers need it most, it is least helpful.
That’s the experience of people like Mark Beales, a retired mortgage banker from Mill Creek, Wash. He said that for simple queries, such as confirming a flight, AI usually provides a fast, accurate answer. But when it comes to complex matters, such as changing a ticket, it falls short. It’s a lot of “I didn’t understand that,” and “Do you want me to repeat those options?”
“Sometimes, a bot can’t answer my questions, which is aggravating,” he said. “I don’t mind dealing with AI – as long as I can get around it when I need.”
Check out Elliott Confidential, the newsletter the travel industry doesn’t want you to read. Each issue is filled with breaking news, deep insights, and exclusive strategies for becoming a better traveler. But don’t tell anyone!
Well, it looks like the travel industry may have a solution, and you’re probably not going to like it.
Travel companies want you to pay extra to bypass the bot.
A ‘human premium’ for customer service?
“Many customers prefer talking to a live representative, especially when dealing with complex issues,” said David Hunt, chief operating officer of Versys Media, a design agency. “I believe we’ll see a human premium for customer service.”
Hunt ought to know. He recently worked with a major airline that found passengers strongly preferred direct human communication during booking.
“For me, this highlighted a clear willingness to pay for human interaction,” said Hunt.
A recent survey found that three-quarters of Americans would pay more for a premium customer service experience (i.e., skipping AI and speaking with a person).
Of course, preferred customer service has always been a staple of the travel experience. If you have a Platinum Card, you can call a dedicated customer service number. If you’re traveling in first class, your customer service call gets preferential treatment. Or, if you want a white-glove travel experience, you can pay a travel advisor for personalized treatment instead of booking through an online travel agency.
Experts say travel companies could take things to the next level. Imagine being on hold with an airline and hearing an offer: “Press 3 to be connected to a human for an additional $25 fee.” As far-fetched as it sounds, travel companies could be mulling such a move.
In a way, it’s already here
The talk-to-a-person fee already exists in the airline industry, to a certain extent. Many airlines charge a fee if you want to speak to a customer service agent instead of using the website to book a ticket. The fees range from $25 to $50 per reservation, depending on your destination. (Some airlines, notably Delta and Southwest, do not charge to talk to a person.)
How much does it cost to book a ticket with a human?
| Airline | Phone Fee (Domestic) | Phone Fee (International) | Notes |
| Alaska Airlines | $15 | $15 | Waived for MVP Gold+ and Club 49 members |
| American Airlines | $50 | $50 | Waived for AAdvantage Executive Platinum/Platinum Pro |
| Delta Air Lines | $0 | $0 | Fees may apply for certain European-origin tickets |
| Hawaiian Airlines | $25 | $35 | Waived for Pualani elite members and cardholders |
| JetBlue | $25 | $25 | Waived for Mosaic members |
| Southwest | $0 | $0 | No fees for phone/airport bookings |
| Spirit Airlines | $25 | $25 | Waived for Spirit Gold members (online/app is cheaper) |
| United Airlines | $25 | $25 | Waived for Premier Silver+ |
Travelers say they would pay more to get human service
I asked travelers how they felt about paying more to avoid AI, and I was surprised by their responses.
“Yes, I would pay extra to speak to a person,” said Raquel Scott, a film producer from Los Angeles. “I absolutely abhor AI chatbots. They are typically a complete waste of time, and sometimes you can’t type what you want to say; you can only click on one of the suggested responses. It’s infuriating!”
Even some insiders say they would pay more to skip the AI.
“I would pay more to speak with a person,” said Mary Zimmerman, a travel advisor. “I think people are increasingly wary of speaking with a robot.”
Others don’t think you should have to pay for human customer service
The idea of charging more to talk to a person doesn’t sit well with everyone.
“When something goes wrong thousands of miles from home – especially while you’re traveling abroad – peace of mind comes from knowing there is a real person on the other end of the line who knows your name and understands the urgency in a way technology can’t,” said Mike Hallman, CEO of Medjet. “And that’s where paying extra for a real person rubs people the wrong way.”
There’s another problem with charging people to speak with a human. Paying to talk to a person may be the only option for those who can least afford it.
“Smartphones, laptops, and other electronic toys are beyond the financial reach of quite a few Americans,” noted Bill McGee, senior fellow at the American Economic Liberties Project.
His organization has taken a position that human-staffed travel call centers should be mandatory, and that regulators should enforce such policies. But in the current “anything goes” regulatory environment, it’s doubtful the government would stop a travel company from offering a “skip the AI” upgrade.
Is there a way around pay-to-play? Possibly, said Emily DeJeu, who teaches business communication at Carnegie Mellon University. You can become a smarter user of technology, finding ways to circumvent a chatbot.
“Long-term, I think we need to apply collective pressure to avoid turning human assistance into a pay-to-play commodity,” she added. The EU is expected to introduce a “Right to Speak to a Human” law by 2028, so it’s possible that government intervention will stop the monetization of human support.
Why the human premium may be one of the worst ideas ever
Should travel companies charge extra to talk to a person? In a word, no. In fact, charging to skip the AI may be one of the worst ideas the travel industry has ever had.
“Charging more to talk to a human undermines trust and signals that empathy is a luxury,” said Mario Matulich, president of Customer Management Practice. “Brands that get this right will flip the script, not penalizing customers for needing help, but designing hybrid experiences where AI empowers agents and real people are accessible when it matters most.”
But why is charging extra such a terrible idea? The reason is simple. In a way, charging extra for human service is an acknowledgment that the AI-dependent system doesn’t work. And that’s a terrible message to send to your customers, especially someone who is trying to rebook a canceled flight or change a room reservation.
Paying a human premium monetizes something that should be included with every product a company offers. Businesses that try to unbundle customer service are playing a dangerous monetization game with their customers. And they stand to lose far more than they can imagine.