Study finds one in 10 binge drinkers drives
Half who drove leaving bar, club or restaurant had seven or more drinks
ATLANTA – One in 10 binge drinkers got behind the wheel the last time they drank heavily. And half of those drivers left from a bar, restaurant or nightclub after downing five or more drinks, a new study has found.
The study is being called the first to try to measure the likelihood someone will drive after binge drinking. It suggests a need for stepped-up efforts to prevent bars and restaurants from serving people after they’re intoxicated, according to its authors at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
The researchers focused on 14,000 “binge drinkers” – people who said that at least once a month they had five or more drinks on a single occasion. About 12 percent said they had gone driving within two hours of their last bout of heavy drinking.
Of those drivers, more than half took the wheel after drinking in a bar, restaurant or other licensed establishment. And half of the drivers who left an establishment said they had seven or more drinks; a quarter said they’d had at least 10.
Some people can handle alcohol better than others, and eating food or drinking over several hours can soften alcohol’s impact. But clearly 10 drinks is a lot, said James Fell, of the Pacific Institute for Research and Evaluation, a national research organization focused on alcohol policy.
“Almost everybody’s going to be intoxicated after 10 drinks,” said Fell, who was not involved in the study.
Binge drinking is a main factor behind the more than 11,000 deaths annually from alcohol-related motor vehicle crashes, said Dr. Timothy Naimi, an epidemiologist with the CDC’s alcohol program. He led the study, which was to be released today and appear in the October issue of the American Journal of Preventive Medicine.
Nearly every state has a law that in theory prohibits licensed establishments from selling alcohol to drunk patrons. But most states don’t have enough enforcement personnel to stop in on bars and watch for overserving of customers.
“These are among the most disregarded laws in the country,” Naimi said.
Without policing, there’s little incentive for bars, clubs and restaurants to discourage drinking. Tips depend on keeping patrons happy and buying, noted Jim Mosher, a Washington, D.C.-based legal researcher and consultant on alcohol issues.
The American Beverage Institute, a restaurant trade association, had no immediate comment on the study Monday. The organization’s Web site promotes efforts to apprehend and penalize drunken drivers, but also notes voluntary server training and other efforts by restaurants to discourage drunken driving.
The CDC study was based on a telephone survey done in 2003 and 2004, and some things have changed since then. Drunken driving fatalities have decreased, dropping nearly 10 percent from 2007 to 2008, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. There have also been a variety of efforts to reduce drunken driving including court-mandated devices that prevent a car from starting if a driver is drunk.
But most efforts focus on punishing the driver and not preventing drunken driving by focusing on those who enable it.
“The drinking location is really important,” Naimi said. “We’re trusting these licensed establishments to serve responsibly, and more than half of the intoxicated people who drive have been drinking in these places.”
A follow-up survey in 2008 found the situation hadn’t changed, he added. Those results haven’t yet been released.