Scofflaws beware: Spokane’s parking enforcement officers may soon quietly whir through city streets on electric power.
City officials introduced a proposal on Monday to lease five new electric subcompact SUVs for parking enforcement officers.
The vehicles would be leased under a one-year pilot program that will inform Spokane leaders how they can best transition the city’s entire fleet of vehicles to electric power as gasoline engines are slowly phased out.
The new plan is the culmination of a monthslong push by Spokane City Council members who questioned proposals to lease traditional gasoline and hybrid electric vehicles.
Charging infrastructure has been at the center of the debate with city officials reluctant to deploy electric vehicles without adequate means to power them. Council members have countered that such infrastructure won’t be built until there’s a demand for it, and the city’s adoption of electric vehicles is a great way to jump-start the process.
In the proposal outlined for the council’s Urban Experience committee on Monday, the parking meter department weighed the benefits of leasing five all-electric Hyundai Konas against Toyota RAV-4 hybrid-electric cars.
In terms of upfront cost, the RAV-4 is the clear winner. The annual lease price of the Kona is $7,336 compared to $6,195 for the RAV-4.
But the gap narrows when other factors are considered, according to the city’s analysis. Officials expect to see savings from the Kona in annual maintenance and fuel.
Assuming each car is driven 9,000 miles a year, the city estimates the Kona will cost about $549 more than the RAV-4 annually.
Those calculations don’t account for an expected increase in insurance premiums – which officials warn could increase by about 20% – or the cost of eventually installing charging stations in parking enforcement headquarters at the Spokane Intermodal Center.
Still, the inflated price tag might be a fair price to pay for the lessons gleaned by integrating more electric vehicles into the city fleet, officials argue. Funding for the vehicles is already included in the Parking Meter Department’s annual budget.
The new vehicles will replace the one Ford Escort and four GO-4 parking enforcement vehicles. The GO-4s have three wheels and are designed to nimbly make their way through city streets but are limited by inclement weather and a shorter range.
“We chose to go with these vehicles specifically, and maybe not something smaller, because they do need to be able to haul cargo, such as car boots,” explained Nathan Groh, the city’s sustainable transportation analyst.
The city would sign a three-year lease on the new cars with Enterprise Fleet Services, but its terms would allow the city to re-evaluate the program every year and bail if necessary.
That was important to Spokane City Council President Breean Beggs – a champion of electrification.
The real savings in going electric, Beggs argued, is that the vehicles last twice as long.
“I’m supportive of the lease for the next year, but I hope we’ll start looking at purchases because that’s where we’ll save a lot of money,” Beggs said.
Beggs has repeatedly expressed concern that the city is failing to abide by state law, which requires cities to replace traditional vehicles with electric models whenever practicable.
Last year, he proposed a law that would require the city to not only meet standards under state law, but force city officials to notify the Public Infrastructure and Environmental Sustainability Committee when they plan to purchase a vehicle that isn’t electric.
Local journalism is essential.
Give directly to The Spokesman-Review's Northwest Passages community forums series -- which helps to offset the costs of several reporter and editor positions at the newspaper -- by using the easy options below. Gifts processed in this system are not tax deductible, but are predominately used to help meet the local financial requirements needed to receive national matching-grant funds.
Subscribe to the Coronavirus newsletter
Get the day’s latest Coronavirus news delivered to your inbox by subscribing to our newsletter.